american journey vs purina pro plan

Purina Pro vs. American Journey: Which Food is Better For Dogs?

When it comes to choosing the best food for your dog, there are a lot of factors to consider. Two of the most popular brands on the market are Purina Pro and American Journey . So, which one is better?

It really depends on your dog’s individual needs. If your dog has sensitive stomach or skin, for example, you might want to choose a food that is specifically designed for those issues. However, if your dog is generally healthy, either brand should be fine.

In terms of price, American Journe y is typically cheaper than Purina Pro . However, Purina Pro often runs specials and coupons, so it’s worth checking their website before you make your final decision.

Ultimately, the best way to decide which food is better for your dog is to talk to your veterinarian. They will be able to recommend a food that is tailored to your dog’s specific needs.

Alternative To Victor Dog Food

Alternative to Purina Pro Plan

American Journey vs Purina Pro Plan Complete Essentials In-Depth Comparison

When it comes to choosing the right food for your dog, there are many options on the market. Two of the most popular brands are American Journey and Purina Pro Plan. Both brands offer dry food options, but there are some differences between them.

The American Journey dry food is available on Chewy.com. It is made with sweet potatoes and has a sweet potato recipe. The Purina Pro Plan Complete Essentials dry food is also available on Chewy.com. It is made with real chicken and does not have a sweet potato recipe.

The American Journey dry food is cheaper than the Purina Pro Plan Complete Essentials dry food. However, the Purina Pro Plan dry food is more nutritious and has more protein.

When it comes to choosing the right food for your dog, it is important to compare the options and decide what is best for your pet.

Alternative To Purina Pro Plan

Pro Plan Adult Wet Dog Food

Is American Journey good dog food?

Yes, American Journey is good dog food. The ingredients are high quality and the company uses responsibly sourced ingredients. The food is also affordable and the company offers a variety of flavors and formulas to choose from.

What company owns American Journey dog food?

Chewy owns American Journey dog food. American Journey is a pet food company that makes all-natural dog food. Their ingredients are sustainably sourced and they use no artificial preservatives, flavors, or colors.

Is Purina Pro Plan better than American journey?

There are many factors to consider when choosing the best food for your dog. American Journey and Purina Pro Plan are two popular brands that offer a variety of formulas for small and large breeds. So, which one is better?

Generally speaking, Purina Pro Plan is considered better than American Journey. The quality is much higher, and the ingredients are more beneficial for dogs, especially large breeds. For example, Purina Pro Plan formulas contain glucosamine, which is great for joint health.

Of course, every dog is different, so it’s always best to consult with your veterinarian to see which food they recommend for your pup. But if you’re looking for a high-quality food that’s great for most dogs, Purina Pro Plan is a good choice.

Best Alternative to American Journey

Best For Puppies

Alternative To American journey

Is American Journey chewy brand?

American Journey is a chewy brand that offers a variety of dry food, treats, supplements, and more for dogs and cats. Chewy is known for their wide selection of pet food and supplies, as well as their commitment to quality and customer service.

American Journey is a relatively new brand, but it has quickly become one of Chewy’s top-selling brands. American Journey dry food is made with high-quality ingredients and contains no fillers or artificial preservatives. The company also offers a variety of treats, supplements, and other products to help keep your pet healthy and happy. American Journey is a trusted brand that offers quality products at an affordable price, and Chewy is proud to offer this brand to our customers.

Is American Journey dog food Aafco certified?

American Journey Dog Food is Aafco certified, which means it meets the nutritional guidelines set forth by the American Association of Feed Control Officials. This food is made with added vitamins and minerals to ensure your dog gets the nutrients they need to stay healthy and active.

Is American Journey good for puppies?

American Journey is a good dry dog food for puppies compared to other dry dog foods. It is a source of animal protein and has a higher percentage of crude protein than most other dry dog foods.

Where To Buy American Journey Cat Food?

You can purchase American Journey Cat Food at your local pet store, or online at Amazon.com. American Journey Cat Food is a premium food that offers high-quality ingredients and nutrition for your cat. The food is made in the USA and contains no fillers or artificial ingredients.

Does Purina Pro Plan have taurine?

Yes, Purina Pro Plan does have taurine. Taurine is an amino acid that is found in animal tissue, and it is important for the proper functioning of many organs, including the heart. It can also help to improve cognitive function and reduce stress levels.

Is Purina Pro Plan good for dogs?

Yes, Purina Pro Plan is good for dogs. It is a high-quality food that contains all of the nutrients that dogs need to stay healthy and active. The company also offers a wide variety of flavors and formulas to choose from, so you can find the perfect food for your dog’s individual needs.

Is Purina Pro Plan dog food grain free?

Yes, Purina Pro Plan dog food is grain free. All of the ingredients in our products are carefully selected to provide your dog with the nutrition they need to live a long and healthy life.

Which Purina Pro Plan formula is best for my dog?

The best Purina Pro Plan formula for your dog largely depends on their individual needs and preferences. For example, some dogs may do better on a grain-free diet while others may need a higher protein content to maintain their energy levels. Ultimately, it is important to consult with your veterinarian to make sure you are choosing the right formula for your furry friend.

Where can I buy Purina Pro Plan?

There are many places where you can buy Purina Pro Plan. You can find it in most pet stores, or online. It is important to read the ingredients and choose a formula that is right for your pet’s needs.

Purina Pro vs. American Journey: Omega fatty acids for skin and coat health.

There are many factors to consider when choosing the right food for your dog. Two of the most important factors are the quality of ingredients and the nutritional needs of your individual dog. When it comes to omega fatty acids, both Purina Pro and American Journey offer excellent options for skin and coat health.

Purina Pro’s Omega-3 Formula is designed to support a healthy coat and skin. It contains high levels of omega-3 fatty acids, which are essential for maintaining healthy skin and coat. The formula also includes other nutrients that support overall health, including vitamins A and E.

American Journey’s Salmon & Sweet Potato Recipe is also rich in omega-3 fatty acids. In addition to promoting healthy skin and coat, this recipe also provides other important nutrients like antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals.

Purina Pro vs. American Journey: Meat by-product meals Comparison

There are many brands of pet food on the market, and it can be hard to choose the right one for your pet. If you’re looking for a food that uses meat by-product meals, you may be wondering if Purina Pro or American Journey is the better option.

Both brands use meat by-product meals in their foods, but Purina Pro also uses corn, wheat, and soy in their foods. American Journey does not use any of these ingredients.

So, if you’re looking for a food that is free of corn, wheat, and soy, American Journey is the better choice. However, if you’re not concerned about those ingredients, Purina Pro may be a better option for you.

Affiliate Disclosure

DogFoodThink is a participant in the Chewy and Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, we earn commission from qualifying purchases through links. As a Chewy affiliate, we may earn commissions for qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

As a Chewy affiliate, I earn commissions for qualifying purchases.

Don’t disregard advice from a vet. We may direct you to retailers such as Chewy or Amazon that provide us with a tiny commission on resulting sales. This comes at no extra cost to you.

© Dog FoodThink

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Bestie Paws Hospital

Everything You Need To Know!

• 🌐 Contact Us
• Dog Food Review

🤔 Is American Journey a Good Dog Food?

When it comes to choosing the right food for our furry friends, every pet owner wants the best. American Journey, a popular brand available on Chewy, often comes up in discussions. But how does it really stack up?

Understanding American Journey Dog Food

Composition and nutritional value.

American Journey offers a range of formulas including grain-free options and those with grains like brown rice. The brand emphasizes high-quality protein sources such as salmon, chicken, and beef. Let’s break down the key components:

• Protein Source: 🐟🐔🐄 (High-quality options like salmon, chicken, and beef)
• Grain-Free Options: ✔️ (Available for dogs with specific dietary needs)
• Includes Grains: ✔️ (Brown rice and other grains for a balanced diet)

Suitability for Different Dogs

Different dogs have different needs based on their size, age, and health. American Journey caters to these variations with specific formulas:

• Puppy Formulas: ✔️ (Nutrient-rich for growing dogs)
• Senior Dog Formulas: ✔️ (Adjusted for older dogs’ needs)
• Large Breed and Small Breed Formulas: ✔️ (Tailored for size-specific dietary requirements)

Price and Value

• Cost-Effectiveness: 💲💲 (Moderately priced, offering good value for the quality)

User Feedback and Veterinarian Opinions

Opinions on American Journey vary among dog owners and professionals:

• Positive User Reviews: 😊 (Many report their dogs thriving on this food)
• Concerns: 🤔 (Some dogs may experience digestive issues, especially with grain-free options)
• Veterinarian Recommendations: 🏥 (Mixed; some vets recommend it, while others prefer brands with more extensive feeding trials)

Comparing with Other Brands

When stacked against competitors like Purina Pro Plan or Royal Canin, American Journey holds its own in certain aspects but may lack in others:

• Ingredient Quality: Comparable in many respects
• Feeding Trials and Research: 📉 (Less extensive than some leading brands)
• Price: More cost-effective in many cases

Key Takeaways

• Variety of Formulas: Catering to different needs including age, size, and health conditions
• Quality Ingredients: High-quality protein sources and wholesome grains
• Price Point: Offers good value for the quality provided
• Digestive Concerns: Some reports of digestive issues, especially with the grain-free formulas
• Less Research and Feeding Trials: Compared to some industry leaders

Final Thoughts

American Journey dog food appears to be a solid choice for many dog owners, offering a balance of quality, variety, and value. However, it’s crucial to consider your dog’s specific needs and possibly consult a veterinarian, especially if your dog has a sensitive stomach or specific health concerns. As with any dog food choice, it’s about finding the right fit for your individual pet.

Remember : Every dog is unique! What works wonderfully for one may not suit another. Always monitor your dog’s health and behavior when trying a new food and don’t hesitate to make adjustments as needed.

FAQs on American Journey Dog Food

Is american journey dog food grain-free.

American Journey offers both grain-free and grain-inclusive formulas. The grain-free options are designed for dogs with specific dietary needs or sensitivities to grains. However, it’s important to note that recent studies have raised concerns about the link between grain-free diets and heart issues in dogs. Consulting with a veterinarian before choosing a grain-free diet is advisable.

How Does American Journey Dog Food Support a Dog’s Coat and Skin Health?

Many American Journey formulas contain omega fatty acids, typically derived from ingredients like flaxseed and fish oil. These nutrients are essential for maintaining healthy skin and a shiny coat. Additionally, some formulas are enriched with antioxidants and vitamins that further support skin and coat health.

Are There Any Artificial Preservatives or Colors in American Journey Dog Food?

American Journey prides itself on avoiding artificial preservatives and colors in their dog food. The brand emphasizes natural preservation methods and the use of whole food ingredients for natural coloring.

What Are the Protein Sources in American Journey Dog Food?

American Journey uses a variety of high-quality protein sources. These include deboned salmon, chicken, turkey, beef, and lamb. The choice of protein varies across different formulas, catering to various dietary preferences and needs.

How Does American Journey Address Food Allergies or Sensitivities?

For dogs with food sensitivities or allergies, American Journey offers limited ingredient diets. These formulas focus on a single protein source and exclude common allergens like corn, wheat, and soy. This approach minimizes the risk of allergic reactions and is beneficial for dogs with sensitive stomachs.

Is American Journey Dog Food Suitable for Puppies and Senior Dogs?

Yes, American Journey offers specific formulas tailored for puppies and senior dogs. Puppy formulas are enriched with DHA for brain development, while senior dog food is adjusted for lower calorie content and includes components to support joint health and mobility.

Can American Journey Dog Food Aid in Weight Management?

Certain formulas by American Journey are designed for weight management. These typically have lower calorie content while still providing a balanced and nutritious diet. They are ideal for dogs prone to weight gain or those needing a less energy-dense diet.

How Does American Journey Ensure the Quality and Safety of Its Products?

American Journey follows rigorous quality control standards. Their manufacturing processes include multiple safety checks and adherence to federal and industry standards for pet food production. Additionally, they source high-quality ingredients and conduct regular testing to ensure product safety and consistency.

Is American Journey Dog Food Recommended for Active or Working Dogs?

American Journey has formulas that are suitable for active or working dogs, providing a higher calorie content and increased levels of protein and fat. These formulations are designed to meet the energy requirements of highly active canines.

Are There Any Specific Formulas for Dogs with Joint Issues?

Yes, some American Journey formulas include ingredients like glucosamine and chondroitin, which are known to support joint health. These components are particularly beneficial for larger breeds and older dogs prone to joint issues.

Does American Journey Dog Food Cater to Dogs with Specific Flavor Preferences?

American Journey offers a diverse range of flavors in their dog food line, including unique protein sources like duck and venison, which cater to dogs with particular taste preferences or those who may be bored with traditional flavors. This variety ensures that even picky eaters can find a flavor they enjoy.

What Role Do Carbohydrates Play in American Journey Dog Food?

Carbohydrates in American Journey dog food come from sources like sweet potatoes, peas, and brown rice, providing essential energy, fiber, and nutrients. These carbohydrate sources are chosen for their digestibility and nutritional value, supporting overall health and sustained energy levels.

How Does American Journey Support Digestive Health in Dogs?

Many American Journey formulas include dietary fibers from natural sources such as chickpeas and sweet potatoes, promoting healthy digestion. Additionally, some products contain probiotics, which aid in maintaining a balanced gut flora, crucial for optimal digestive health.

Are There Specialized Formulas for Dogs with a High Sensitivity to Food?

For dogs with high food sensitivities, American Journey’s Limited Ingredient line reduces the risk of adverse reactions. These formulas focus on minimal ingredients while still providing complete and balanced nutrition, making them ideal for sensitive dogs.

How Does American Journey Ensure Balanced Nutrition in Its Dog Food?

Each American Journey formula is crafted to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles. This ensures that dogs receive a balanced diet with the right mix of proteins, fats, carbohydrates, vitamins, and minerals necessary for overall health and wellbeing.

What is the Shelf Life of American Journey Dog Food, and How Should It Be Stored?

The shelf life of American Journey dog food varies by product and packaging. Typically, unopened bags have a shelf life of 12 to 18 months. Once opened, the food should be stored in a cool, dry place and ideally used within six weeks. Proper storage is crucial to maintain freshness and nutritional value.

How Does American Journey Address Sustainability and Environmental Impact?

American Journey is conscious of its environmental impact, focusing on sustainable sourcing practices for their ingredients. They also prioritize responsible manufacturing processes to minimize their ecological footprint, reflecting a commitment to environmental stewardship.

Are There Options for Dogs with Low Activity Levels in the American Journey Range?

Yes, American Journey provides options for dogs with lower activity levels. These formulas are typically lower in calories and fat to prevent unnecessary weight gain while still supplying all the necessary nutrients for a healthy lifestyle.

Does American Journey Offer Wet Dog Food Options?

American Journey includes wet dog food in its product range, providing a variety of textures and flavors. Wet food can be a good option for dogs who prefer a softer texture or require higher moisture content in their diet.

How Frequently Does American Journey Update Their Formulas?

American Journey continuously evaluates and updates their formulas based on the latest nutritional research and feedback from pet owners and professionals. This ensures their products remain innovative, nutritionally up-to-date, and in line with the best practices in pet nutrition.

• American Journey Dog Food: The In-Depth Review
• ⚖️ American Journey Dog Food Lawsuit
• Does PetSmart Accept American Express?
• 🌆 5 Safest Central American Countries for Expats
• 🧭 FDA Approval for Food Products: A Step-by-Step…

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Bark-Worthy Bites: Unveiling Our Best Dog Food Brands

Ma. Leonor Dollisen

Updated on:

  Disclaimer: The information contained in this post is the researched opinion of the writer and should not be substituted for experienced medical advice from a licensed Veterinary specialist.

All dog owners want the best for their pets and one of the most important decisions they can make is their choice of dog food.

Whether you are a new pet parent or an experienced veteran, this decision can be rather daunting. With so many different pet food labels out there, how can you best determine what is the right food for your dog? Are there tips in choosing the best dog food?

Our guide is here to make that process much simpler. It will teach you the difference between bad and good pet food, and help you make an informed decision on  what will best benefit your dog .  Below are our worst   &   best dog food brand reviews, read on.

12. Natural Balance LID Sweet Potato & Venison Recipe

1. sportmix premium high energy 26/18.

Best Dog Food Brands

1. ollie turkey recipe.

First 5 ingredients:

Turkey, Butternut Squash, Turkey Livers, Oats, Lentils

Protein: 10.0% min

Fat: 7.0% min

Fiber: 2.0% max

Moisture: 72.0% max

Food Type: Coarse Pâté

Best for: All Breed, All Life Stages

Ollie is created by canine nutritionists , a raw food system designed to give your pet optimum nutrition in a limited ingredient formula.

Everything is  created using restaurant grade ingredients  and shipped within days of getting made. It’s easy to set up your account and manage things based on your dog’s needs. If you’ve got the extra budget, it’s worth it.

The limited ingredients present in Ollie's formula makes it a great option for dogs with sensitive stomachs and will help prevent potential allergic reactions.

By cutting out the plant proteins that are typically found in dry dog foods to boost the protein content, your dog will be less likely to suffer from digestive distress.

Ollie is perfect even for the pickiest of dogs. Of the four unique vet-crafted recipes on offer, we would recommend the Turkey Recipe option. It incorporates turkey breast, turkey liver, kale, carrots, blueberries and chia seeds to provide a flavor and texture that is unrivaled.

This is a grain-free dog food and contains no fillers. The meat is also sourced from farms that provide vegetable-fed and hormone-free turkey. All these factors make Ollie a step above other luxury formulas.

Whole fruits and veggies provide excellent doses of vitamins and minerals, which helps with immune support, while coconut oil and cod liver oil contains essential fatty acids for maintaining skin and coat health.

Everything is packaged in easy to use portion sizes, so there’s no confusion about how much to feed each mealtime. This is the closest to a homemade dog food out there.

Fill out a questionnaire for your dog and receive perfectly portioned meals. Put them in your refrigerator or freezer, and they’re ready to serve when you are.

Despite its steep price point, we truly believe that it is the best dog food label on the market today. We feel confident in stating that your pooch will love it, and you would to if you tasted it!

Fresh dog food

Well-sourced ingredients

Delivered to your door

Regular deliveries

Perfect for sensitive pets

Raw nutrition with limited ingredients

Weekly and biweekly delivery not available for some areas

2. Open Farm Freeze Dried Raw Lamb Recipe

Lamb, Lamb Liver, Lamb Heart, Ground Lamb Bone, Butternut Squash

Protein: 38.0% min

Fat: 32.0% min

Fiber: 5.0% max

Moisture: 5.0% max

Food Type: Freeze Dried, Raw

Open Farm brand of dog food is widely regarded as a low-risk option for canine nutrition. With an average carbohydrate content of 10% and protein content of 40%, it stands out for its balanced nutritional profile.

Enriched with essential vitamins and minerals, most variants boast high-quality ingredients such as grass-fed, pasture-raised, and grass-finished beef, along with wild-caught fish (excluding farmed salmon oil).

While a couple of offerings have slightly higher carbohydrate levels than anticipated, the overall ingredient quality remains commendable, featuring organic produce.

This single-protein formula showcases 100% pasture-raised New Zealand raw lamb , complemented by organic vegetables and superfoods, promoting holistic well-being in your furry companion.

As the brand introduces their new look, customers should be aware that during the transition phase, they may receive either the original or updated packaging, based on inventory availability.

Lightly processed

Ingredients 100% traceable

Fat content is less

Lamb used is from New Zealand

Features all organic produce

Fish components are sourced from the wild

Salmon oil appears farmed

Does not provide omega-6 : omega-3 ratio

3. Redbarn Naturals Beef Recipe

Beef, Beef Lung, Beef Liver, Wheat Flour, Egg Product

Protein: 14.0% min

Fat: 6.0% min

Fiber: 3.0% max

Moisture: 43.0% max

Food Type: Semi Moist

Best for: All Life Stages, Small – Large Breeds

Beef stands as a cherished choice among canines and is prominently featured as the primary ingredient in this formula, comprising over 50% of the recipe. Renowned for its high-quality protein content , beef provides all the essential amino acids vital for your pup's well-being.

We appreciate the substantial meat content in the food, ensuring ample energy for your furry friend's daily activities while also enhancing satiety.

Although the absence of vegetables is notable , the inclusion of flaxseed compensates by offering significant nutrients such as magnesium, iron, calcium, vitamin B-6, and omega fatty acids.

Crafted with a single protein source , this formulation caters well to pups with sensitivities to specific animal proteins, provided they are not allergic to beef.

The texture of the food rolls is dense yet easily cut to desired portions, suitable for both training treats and smaller pups. While the texture may crumble under pressure, a hint of smoky aroma suggests a potential smoky flavor profile.

Upon scrutinizing the ingredients, no concerning components are found, although a touch of fruit or vegetables could enhance the nutritional profile further.

Single-protein recipe

Locally made (USA)

Zero artificial preservatives, flavors or colors

Very versatile: meal, treat, topper or pill concealer

Funky smell

Not for sensitive tummies

4. Jinx Salmon, Sweet Potato & Carrot

Salmon, Turkey Meal, Chickpeas, Lentils, Ground Peas

Protein: 27.0% min

Fat: 14.0% min

Moisture: 10.0% max

Food Type: Dry

Best for: Adult, Small – Large Breeds

Packed with natural sources of omega fatty acids, this formula is crafted to promote optimal skin and coat health in your four-legged friend. A suitable choice to feed your dog who is suffering from allergy or sensitivities.

With real salmon leading the ingredient list, you can have confidence in providing your dog with a high-quality protein source. Complementing this, the recipe incorporates superfoods, probiotics, heart-healthy taurine, and essential vitamins and minerals.

The addition of sweet potato serves to enhance natural fiber intake , aiding digestion, while the supplementary vitamins and minerals contribute to bolstering your dog's immune system.

As an added benefit, this dry kibble is devoid of artificial preservatives, corn, wheat, soy, fillers, and byproducts , ensuring a pure and nourishing meal for your cherished companion.

Made from real Salmon

With BC30 probiotics

Free from any grains

Contains over 20 superfoods

Ideal for pets with sensitivities

Rich in Vitamins A, E and C

Not a hit among picky eaters

5. I and love and you Naked Essentials Lamb & Bison

Lamb, Chicken Meal, Turkey Meal, Dried Garbanzo Beans, Dried Lentils

Protein: 30.0% min

Fat: 15.0% min

Fiber: 4.0% max

Moisture: 4.0% max

Special Diet: Grain-Free

Crafted as a grain-free dry food , this formula is expertly tailored to meet the nutritional requirements of dogs across all breeds, sizes, and life stages.

Brimming with flavor and nutrition derived from wholesome ingredients, this multi-protein recipe is designed to satisfy your dog's palate and dietary needs.

Lamb takes center stage as the predominant ingredient in this Naked Essentials formula. Sourced from free-range environments where they graze on pasture, lamb is renowned for its nutritional richness.

Packed with essential nutrients such as selenium, zinc, vitamin B12, and B3, along with omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids, lamb meat offers a myriad of health benefits.

Furthermore, this lamb and bison recipe incorporates flaxseeds, known for their high fiber content and abundance of omega fatty acids.

Rich in lignans, flaxseeds boast potential cardiovascular benefits and may aid in cancer prevention. Their anti-inflammatory properties can alleviate symptoms of arthritis, regulate blood pressure, enhance kidney function, and promote healthy skin and coat in dogs.

Nevertheless, some owners of dogs allergic to chicken were surprised to discover chicken in a lamb and bison recipe. If you have a dog with any form of food allergies or sensitivities, it's essential to thoroughly review the full list of ingredients before buying any product.

Additionally, consider opting for limited ingredient recipes or single-source protein foods specifically designed for such pets.

Free from grains

Enriched with Taurine

Rich in Omega fatty acids

Loaded with pre and probiotics

Free of any fillers or by-products

Has chicken (not for allergic pets)

Caused diarrhea in some dogs

6. A Pup Above Porky Luau

Pork, Pork Liver, Sweet Potatoes, Pork Bone Broth, Green Beans

Protein: 13.6% min

Fat: 5.2% min

Fiber: 1.6% max

Moisture: 73.4% max

Food Type: Fresh

This is a frozen dog food that brings the essence of homemade meals straight to your pup's bowl. Loaded with high protein, low carbs, and abundant collagen and healthy amino acids, this nutrient-packed meal offers your furry friend a whole foods diet they'll adore.

Crafted with human-grade ingredients , this grain-inclusive food combines pork and pineapples with non-GMO, pesticide-free veggies to form a hearty recipe that your pup will devour! With a higher caloric content, it's best suited for more active dogs.

Utilizing a unique sous-vide cooking method , it creates a naturally savory gravy for optimal hydration and irresistible taste sensations. Featuring traceable ingredients (pork, sweet potatoes, green beans, and pineapple), each mouthful transports your pup to paradise.

Treat your canine companion to the ultimate dining experience with this delicious meal.

Single source protein

100% human-grade

Boasts non-GMO veggies

Enriched with superfoods

With nutritious bone broth

Promotes joint and digestive support

7. Blue Buffalo Homestyle Recipe Puppy 

Chicken, Chicken Broth, Chicken Liver, Carrots, Peas

Protein: 9.0% min

Fiber: 1.3% max

Moisture: 78.0% max

Food Type: Wet, Pâté

Best for: Puppy, All Breeds

This specialized canned dog food caters to pups below 12 months , offering tailored feeding guidelines for 1-3 months, 3-5 months, 5-7 months, and 7-12 months. Crafted to support optimal growth into healthy adulthood, it incorporates additional vitamins and minerals uncommon in standard puppy diets.

Ideal for your maturing companion, this delectable wet puppy food boasts an irresistible taste crafted solely from premium natural components. Beginning with top-tier protein sourced from succulent chicken chunks , it is enriched with an array of garden-fresh fruits and vegetables , complemented by essential vitamins and minerals. 

Designed with DHA to bolster brain, eye, and cognitive growth, this pate-style puppy cuisine features wholesome ingredients devoid of any by-product meals, corn, wheat, soy, artificial flavors, or preservatives.

While not grain-free , this canned dog food's grain content remains subject to debate. Nevertheless, this shouldn't deter consideration of this specific dog food for puppies.

Made from real chicken 

Promotes muscle growth

Zero , corn, wheat or soy

With DHA to support brain, eye health

Can be given as a treat, topper or entree

Free from by-product meals, additives and preservatives

Dented cans upon arrival

Caused loose bowels in some

8. Instinct Original Recipe

Chicken, Chicken Meal, Peas, Chicken Fat, Tapioca

Protein: 37.0% min

Fat: 20.0% min

Best for: All Lifestages, All Breeds

Special Diet: Grain-free

Instinct has developed an exceptional grain-free food that excels across the board. The food contains chicken as its primary protein source, sourced exclusively from cage-free chickens.

Each kibble piece contains raw ingredients , a method Nature's Variety believes is optimal for dogs to absorb nutrients. There are no grains, potatoes, corn, wheat, soy, by-product meals, artificial colors, or preservatives included.

This formulation prioritizes minerals and vitamins crucial for your dog's well-being, fostering thriving health. While peas are part of the formula , which may pose issues for dogs with sensitive stomachs, Instinct has addressed this concern.

To mitigate any potential digestive upset, Instinct has fortified this formula with guaranteed levels of live, natural probiotics , as well as natural omegas and antioxidants. These additions support digestive health, promote a healthy skin and coat, and bolster immune function.

Grain-free formula

High protein content

Helps develop strong muscles

Promotes better digestion, coat and skin

Suitable for dogs with food sensitivities

Guaranteed levels of live, natural probiotics

Formula is not consistent

Tummy issues for some pets

9. Purina Pro Plan Bright Mind 7+

Water, Beef, Wheat Gluten, Liver, Brown Rice

Protein: 12.0% min

Fat: 3.0% min

Fiber: 1.5% max

Moisture: 75.0% max

Food Type: Wet, Chunks in Gravy

Best for: Senior, All Breeds

This wet food is specifically crafted for adult dogs aged 7 years and older , aiming to support their mental nourishment throughout their senior phase.

Drawing from Purina's proprietary research, enriched botanical oils serve as a brain fuel source for aging dogs, naturally aiding cognitive function akin to their younger years.

This Purina Pro Plan dog food primarily features real beef , offering a high-quality protein source renowned for its flavor. However, it also includes unspecified animal ingredients such as liver and meat by-products, alongside wheat gluten, which is deemed a lower-grade protein source.

These undisclosed animal ingredient s may pose challenges for senior dogs with food sensitivities, representing inferior quality components.

Despite these ingredient drawbacks, many pet owners have been astounded by the results of this wet dog food for senior dogs. Observing heightened alertness and activity, previously lethargic dogs seem revitalized.

Overall, this wet food comes highly recommended based on its transformative effects on numerous senior pets. Witnessing their renewed vitality and enthusiasm during mealtime brings immense joy to dog parents, making it a worthwhile consideration for owners of senior canine companions. It may be the best food available for your dog that meets his sunset years.

Packed with protein (real beef)

Nourishes skin and coat

Highly palatable (with gravy)

With enhanced botanical oils 

Food is appropriate for seniors

Helps promote alertness and mental sharpness

Too rich for some seniors

10. Merrick Lil' Plates Salmon & Sweet Potato Recipe

Deboned Salmon, Salmon Meal, Whitefish Meal, Sweet Potatoes, Potatoes

Protein: 32.0% min

Fiber: 4.5% max

Moisture: 11.0% max

Best for: All Life Stages, Extra Small – Small Breeds

Lil' Plates represents Merrick’s solution tailored for small breed dogs with hearty appetites, offering a grain-free lineup designed to meet the nutritional demands of petite mouths.

Featuring smaller-sized kibbles in a crunchy texture, this type of food aim to support dental health while providing essential nutrients such as protein, glucosamine, and chondroitin for robust bones and joints.

These recipes prioritize deboned meat as the primary ingredient, omitting corn and soy, and incorporating whole foods, along with prebiotics and probiotics to promote digestive wellness.

The specific Lil' Plates variant featured showcases salmon as the key animal protein source, with deboned salmon leading the ingredient list, complemented by salmon meal and whitefish meal to enrich its nutritional profile.

This formulation also includes three ingredients rich in fat — coconut oil, flaxseed, and sunflower oil — known for their nutritional benefits, including healthy fats and essential fatty acids.

Recognizing the unique dietary requirements of smaller breeds, Merrick's recipe caters to their accelerated metabolism, ensuring adequate nutrition beyond what is typical for larger canines.

Addressing the size of the kibbles and nutrient levels, this formula comprehensively meets the dietary needs of small breed dogs.

Made from real salmon

Helps reduce plaque

Promotes better skin and shiny coat

Probiotics added for optimal digestion

Filled with natural chondroitin and glucosamine

Strong seafood scent

Picky eaters are not a fan

11. Holistic Select Large & Giant Breed

Chicken Meal, Rice, Oatmeal, Oats, Chicken Fat

Protein: 24.0% min

Fat: 13.0% min

Best for: All Life Stages, Large-Giant Breeds

This dog food works specifically for large dogs , featuring a meal that's tailored to their larger mouths and unique digestive requirements. This natural dry dog food is designed with larger kibble sizes to accommodate the size of their mouths, ensuring comfortable chewing and digestion.

At the core of this recipe is their proprietary Digestive Health Support System , which incorporates active probiotics, healthy fiber, and digestive enzymes. These components work synergistically to promote optimal digestive function, aiding in the breakdown and absorption of essential nutrients. By supporting a healthy digestive system, this formula facilitates the efficient utilization of nutrients throughout your dog's entire body, promoting overall wellness.

In addition to the Digestive Health Support System, this recipe is enriched with high-quality, natural ingredients , including chicken meal and oatmeal. These components provide a rich source of protein, carbohydrates, and essential nutrients, contributing to your dog's overall health and vitality.

With consistent use, this all-inclusive approach to nutrition ensures that your dog not only looks healthy on the outside but also feels healthy from within.

Supports healthy digestion

No poultry or meat by-products

Free from gluten, wheat or fillers

Filled with antioxidant-rich superfoods

Zero artificial flavor, color or preservatives

Rich in taurine, glucosamine and Omega fatty acids

Not that appealing 

Kibble size too small for giant breeds

Sweet Potatoes, Potatoes, Venison Broth, Venison, Potato Protein

Protein: 7.0% min

Fat: 4.0% min

Best for: All Life Stages, All Breeds

Natural Balance is dedicated to crafting Limited Ingredient formulas tailored to fulfill your dog's nutritional requirements without sacrificing taste or quality!

This canned wet food is a grain-free allergy formula crafted specifically for adult dogs prone to sensitivities caused by proteins, carbohydrates, and food additives commonly found in many different brands. 

This single protein recipe features venison paired with sweet potatoes, a highly digestible source of energy. Not only is this formula appetizing and gentle on the stomach (suitable food for sensitive stomachs), but it also supports healthy skin and digestion thanks to the inclusion of salmon oil. Moreover, it ensures overall well-being by addressing all of your furry friend's nutritional needs!

Smooth and velvety , the pâté texture of this canned food ensures a luxurious dining experience for your furry companion. As your dog takes a bite, they'll encounter a consistency that's not too dense nor too loose, striking the perfect balance for easy consumption and enjoyment.

Designed by veterinarians for dogs dealing with allergies, skin irritations, and respiratory issues, this formula is enriched with essential vitamins B6 and B12, crucial for maintaining a healthy metabolism and gastrointestinal function throughout every stage of life.

Suitable for all life stages

Highly digestible formula

Balanced and complete meal

Limited number of ingredients

Ideal for highly sensitive pets

Cans only 3/4 full

Sudden change in consistency (runny)

5 Dog Food Related Trends Heading into 2024

• Fresh Pet Food Delivery – More and more companies are being created that offer fresh food delivered to your door. These services typically craft a recipe that has been personalized for your dog's specific dietary needs. They are quite often expensive and are therefore not affordable for a lot of dog owners. With that being said, some consider these to be the safest dog food options.
• Pea Free Formulas – Following an FDA study in 2018 , there has been a link found between canine heart disease and grain-free diets. This has been linked to the usage of potatoes, lentils, legumes, and peas in grain-free formulas. Check out our 9 Best Dog Foods without Peas.
• Transparency – Consumers are increasingly demanding to know where the ingredients in recipes come from. Sites are being established online to investigate the effects filler and substitute ingredients can have on dogs.
• Personalization – Many companies are crafting lines for dogs with specific dietary requirements. Limited ingredient diets are becoming increasingly popular as a way of preventing food allergies in dogs.
• Focus on Research and Feeding Trials – The 2018 FDA study has sparked a wave of research and feeding trials into the effects of a grain-free diet.

Our Worst Dog Food Brands 

All pet foods are not created equal but most of the low-quality dog food brands have a few things in common. Some of the worst brands on the market load up their products with inexpensive fillers like corn and wheat products – their products also tend to be carb-heavy instead of meat-based.

Low-quality pet formulas make heavy use of by-products and plant proteins , plus they often use artificial colors and flavors to make their products more palatable for pets and the people who care for them. 

Something else many of these foods have in common is a history of product recalls by their manufacturing company.

Below is an overview of our 10 worst dog foods as of this writing . We started our list with recipes that contain dubious and low-quality ingredients and worked our way down to the worst offenders with recent recalls under their belt.

10. ALPO Come & Get It! Cookout Classics

ALPO  is a known dog food brand that may look to many as a quality pet food. But as turns out, it’s not. Or at least, this particular recipe isn’t.

This formulation does not start with meat . In fact, the first meat ingredient won’t be found until the 3rd slot in the list. And the only other meat is in 6th place. 

What starts off this food is ground yellow corn, meaning that corn has the most significant volume in the diet. Not only that, there are two more corn ingredients in the recipe and one legume.

It’s a formulation that focuses more on carbohydrates rather than protein. (The minimum crude protein is only equivalent to 18%.) It meets the AAFCO dog food nutrient profile, yes, but does not really go much above it.

The second thing we don’t like is the inclusion of artificial food coloring . Color is not a requirement in dog food, and dogs will be better off without it. The less artificial ingredients in dog food, the better. 

This kibble is the least of the worst dog foods in our list because it contains real and named meat ingredients. 

Recall Info:  None for this recipe, and the only recall for the ALPO brand happened way back in 2007 for possible melamine contamination.

Problem Ingredients:  Ground yellow corn, corn germ meal, soybean meal, corn gluten meal, Red 40, Yellow 5, Blue 2, Yellow 6.

9. Kal Kan Complete Adult Food For Dogs

Touted as a complete and balanced dog food diet, the Kal Kan Complete adult food is advertised to contain all the protein necessary to provide dogs with enough stamina and energy.

While it does make good on its promise, we can’t help but check the label to see if it really is as good as it sounds. And that’s where it went downhill. 

The first ingredient in this recipe is ground yellow corn . Now a dish that doesn’t start with meat is already low-quality in our opinion (unless the food was created specifically to address a medical condition or is a special diet), but the corn is supported by many more carb ingredients in the food. 

Aside from corn, there is one more corn product ( corn gluten meal ), two grain products ( wheat middlings and ground wheat ), and one legume ( soybean meal ) ingredient. Three of them are in the first five of the ingredients list. 

Now let’s move on to the meats, they’re both unspecified . Meat and bone meal does not refer to which animal contributed to the meal.

It’s a vague term that could mean either one type of animal meat was used or a lot. If your pet is particularly sensitive to some types of animal protein, then it becomes even more worrying. You don’t know what you’re feeding your pup.

Another thing is the use of the term ‘chicken by-product meal.’ When meat is simply stated as ‘chicken’ then it refers to the chicken’s muscle meat.

Throw in the word ‘by-product’ and that becomes open to interpretation. Anything leftover from processing meat is considered a byproduct. So you can get meat and organs, but you could also be getting entrails, feathers, and more. 

Recall Info:  None yet. 

Problem Ingredients:  Ground yellow corn, meat and bone meal, soybean meal, ground wheat, chicken by-product meal, wheat middlings, corn gluten meal.

8. Purina Dog Chow Complete With Real Chicken

It’s proudly tagged as having 23 vitamins and minerals as well as containing real chicken, so you’d expect it to be a healthy chicken-based dish for your pup. But that would be wrong.

There is no chicken to be found within the first five ingredients. But where’s the chicken? It’s in the 7th slot, after the corns and legume.

We’ll list down the first five ingredients here: Whole Grain Corn, Meat And Bone Meal, Corn Gluten Meal, Beef Fat, Soybean Meal . That’s a significant amount of corn and soybean when put together.

We don’t have a problem with corn. We recognize that corn contains nutrients and is not a filler. In most cases. However, for a recipe that’s not formulated to target specific canine medical conditions, we’d expect the corn to be merely a supporting ingredient and not the main one. Quality dog food should always contain more meat than carbohydrates. 

The second thing we’ve noticed is that most of the meats are unnamed . That’s a red flag in dog food. While an unspecified meat ingredient will not harm your pup, it’s kind of worrying that you don’t know what’s going in your pet’s food. It’ll even be more worrying if your pet turns out to be sensitive to the ingredient included.

There’s meat and bone meal and poultry by-product meal. What meat do these refer to? Pork, beef, chicken? What kind of poultry? Turkey or chicken?

And since we’re talking about byproducts too, which parts were used? Muscle meat, organs, entrails? The fresh chicken (which the name of the product is referring to) doesn’t appear until the 7th slot.

And lastly, this recipe contains artificial food coloring which is totally unnecessary and not beneficial to dogs.

Recall Info:  There is no recall history for this specific product although the Purina brand has been involved in several recalls since 2011. 

Problem Ingredients:  Whole Grain Corn, Meat And Bone Meal, Corn Gluten Meal, Soybean Meal, Poultry By-Product Meal, Yellow 6, Yellow 5, Red 40, Blue 2.

7. Kibbles ‘n Bits Homestyle Grilled Beef & Vegetable

At first glance, this recipe looks alright. It’s promoted as having a culinary-inspired formula and is supposed to be loaded with proteins.

The texture — crunchy kibbles with soft, meaty bits — is also something that would definitely interest a pup. However, if you look closely at the label, you’ll see that the food is made up of low-quality ingredients .

It’s not meat-based . Although it’s billed as a beef and vegetable recipe, the vegetables come first and there are more of them than necessary.

In fact, the main ingredients of the meal are corn and grains . The meat doesn’t come in until the third slot. and it’s the only meat within the first eight ingredients of the recipe (if you don’t count animal fat. We don’t).

We don’t usually have a problem with corn or grains, but this many? And it’s not only that. There’s corn syrup in the food. While corn syrup is not a dangerous ingredient, it has a high sugar content.

It’s not necessary in dog food, and manufacturers only add it to enhance the flavor. If your pup is already struggling with obesity, then this sugar product makes the problem worse. 

Lastly, we’re not a fan of artificial colors, and this food has plenty of it. Dogs aren’t tempted by colored foods, so the artificial hues are really intended to attract pet owners. 

Recall Info:  No food recall for this specific recipe although Kibbles ‘n Bits has been involved in a recall for its canned foods back in 2018. 

Problem Ingredients:  Corn, Soybean Meal, Ground Wheat, Corn Syrup, Wheat Middlings, Titanium Dioxide (Color), Yellow 5, Yellow 6, Wheat Flour, Red 40, Blue 1.

6. Pedigree Complete Nutrition Adult Grilled Steak & Vegetable

This dog food is billed as providing complete nutrition for adult pups and even includes an optimal content of omega fatty acids for shiny hair.

The brand also boasts that it is made of the finest ingredients. Looking closely at the label, however, we see a different story.

The first ingredient of the meal is ground whole grain corn . The third ingredient is also corn (but this time it’s called corn gluten meal) while the fifth is soybean meal.

So in the first 5 slots, you get three corn and legume ingredients, which means that this is not a meat-based dish at all. Here, the meat acts as support only and not the other way around, and there are too many grains.

The second thing we don’t like about this recipe is that it uses unrecognizable animal ingredients. We’re talking about the meat and bone meal.

Meat meals are usually okay provided that the animal the meat comes from is named. For example, chicken meal or lamb meal. But meat and bone meal? Which animal meat was used? Is there more than one kind of animal? And then, which parts? 

Lastly, while the brand says that the recipe does not contain “artificial flavors or sugar,” it does contain artificial colors . There are four we could see, and they’re listed midway in the list, having more volume than the added nutrients the food contains. 

Recall Info:  This dry dog food line was recalled way back in 2014 due to the possible presence of metal fragments in the bags, although no illnesses or injuries were reported. The line has not had a recall since.

Problem Ingredients:  Ground Whole Grain Corn, Meat And Bone Meal, Corn Gluten Meal, Soybean Meal, Brewers Rice, Ground Whole Grain Wheat, Red 40, Yellow 6, Blue 2, Yellow 5.

5. Ol’ Roy Complete Nutrition Roasted Chicken & Rice

Ol’ Roy is a Walmart brand that has been in production since 1981. This specific recipe from the brand is crafted for adult canines of all sizes with essential nutrients to provide a balanced diet.

It’s marked as an inexpensive pet food due to lack of advertising and promotion, but if you look closely at the ingredients, you’ll see another reason why.

We’ll list the first six ingredients here: Ground Whole Grain Corn, Meat and Bone Meal, Soybean Meal, Rice Bran, Animal Fat (preserved with BHA and BHT), and Poultry By-Product Meal. And most of these are problematic.

We don’t have anything against corn. Grains are okay too. In fact, these are healthy ingredients to have in dog food. But within reasonable quantities and never as the most significant part of a diet. In this recipe, the corn and grains make up the most volume and overwhelm the meat.

Second thing, the meats are all unspecified . They’re labelled as meat and bone meal and poultry byproduct meal. The labels don’t indicate exactly what animal the meat comes from and which parts (regarding the byproducts) were used. 

Lastly, the food contains artificial colors and artificial preservatives (BHA and BHT). 

Recall Info:  There has been no recall yet for this formulation, although the Ol’ Roy brand has been involved in several recalls since 1998. The most recent one was in 2018 where samples of its Gravy Train line were found to contain traces of sodium pentobarbital.

Problem Ingredients:  Ground Whole Grain Corn, Meat and Bone Meal, Soybean Meal, Rice Bran, Animal Fat (preserved with BHA and BHT), Poultry By-Product Meal, Red #40, Yellow #5, and Blue #2.

4. Pro Pac Performance Puppy

This recipe is designed for puppies from weaning until the 12th month. It’s also labelled as an excellent feed for pregnant or nursing canines. 

We don’t find anything wrong with the ingredients because it starts with chicken meal, an animal protein. Ground yellow corn as the second ingredient may be a little bit off, but still not bad. What’s more concerning is the recent recall of this product.

The maker of this recipe is Midwestern Pet Foods , the same manufacturer of Sportsmix, Nunn Better, and Splash Fat Cat.

The company is currently embroiled in one of the worst pet food recalls to date concerning aflatoxin, a possibly fatal type of toxin that was found in Midwestern Pet Food’s Sportsmix products. 

Included in the recall are two Pro Pac recipes. This particular formulation and the Pro Pac Adult Mini Chunk. 

Recall Info:  On January 11, 2021, and FDA alert was issued on the Pro Pac Adult Mini Chunk, 40 lb. bags and Pro Pac Performance Puppy, 40 lb. bags manufactured in Midwestern Pet Foods’s Oklahoma plant  (denoted with a “05” in the date/lot code) with expiration dates of July 9, 2022 or earlier. 

This is an expanded recall that was issued out of caution since the Pro Pac recipes were produced in the same plant as the Sportsmix foods that have caused the deaths of more than 70 dogs and the illness of around 80 at least.

Problem Ingredients:  none

3. Sportsman’s Pride Professional Formula 30/20

This is a dog food line geared towards canine athletes and is sold as supportive of the endurance and energy requirements of working dogs and active pups.

While that sounds good, we need to take a look at the recent recall of one of its products (Professional Formula 30/20) and the ingredients it contains.

On June 3, 2021 , the FDA issued an alert regarding one lot of Professional Formula 30/20. Sunshine Mills, Inc., which manufactures Sportsman’s Pride and the brands Sprout, Intimidator, and FRM Gold Select (all involved in the recall), issued a voluntary recall of this recipe for potential salmonella contamination. 

But looking past the recall alert, we’d have to say that this recipe doesn’t meet our standards either. The main ingredient in this food is chicken byproduct meal, a rather dubious ingredient with regards to quality. 

Chicken byproduct can mean any leftover part of the chicken, and not just its organs. With quality recipes, manufacturers generally state “chicken liver, chicken heart, “ and so on.

When a manufacturer lists byproduct only, that means the food may contain a combination of a lot of unsavory things that won’t sound as good when listed down and specified.

Lastly, this food uses more carbs than protein to supply the energy needs of dogs because there are three grain and corn ingredients within the first five slots.

Recall Info:  For possible salmonella contamination, Sunshine Mills recalled the 40 lb bags of Sportsman’s Pride Professional Formula 30/20 Dog Food with a use by date of Oct. 7, 2021. These bags were sold in the states of MS, FL, TN, LA, VA, NC, TX.

The potential for contamination was noted after a sample of 5 lb. Sprout Sporting Dog Food product was collected and tested positive for salmonella during routine surveillance.

Sunshine Mills manufactures the recalled Sprout, Intimidator, Sportsman’s Pride, and FRM Gold Select dog foods  in the same plant. No illnesses or complaints have been reported to date.

Problem Ingredients:  Chicken By-Product Meal, Rice, Corn Meal, Corn Gluten Meal

2. Bravo Packing Performance Dog

We normally like raw pet food because most of these are free from fillers and the meat included are in their purest forms, free from processing of any kind. However, in the case of Bravo Packing’s raw diet, we’d have to rethink this.

Bravo Packing’s ( not to be confused with Bravo Pet Foods ) Performance Dog and all of Bravo Packing’s other raw diets have undergone a recall this year.

Although no deaths or illnesses have been associated with the food, it is troubling that the brand has once again been involved with a recall.

From 2011 to 2015, Bravo had 7 recalls , which included expanded recalls. (Expanded recall means a company had to recall a product then expanded that recall to include other products.)

There was another in 2018 and another in 2019 before the one for 2021. All of the past recalls were due to the possible presence of Salmonella or Listeria .

Recall Info:  On March 3, 2021, Bravo Packing, Inc. issued a voluntary recall of two of their raw pet food products (Ground Beef and Performance Dog frozen raw) for possible cross contamination after samples collected during a  US Food and Drug Administration (FDA ) inspection tested positive for Salmonella and Listeria monocytogenes.

The brand expanded the recall  on March 16 to include ALL of its pet food and bone products of all sizes. No lot code or date code has been provided for the recent recall so assume, for the safety of your pets, that all are possibly contaminated.

This makes the top of our worst dog foods list because of the sheer number of dogs that were affected by the aflatoxin levels found in several Sportsmix products, including this one.

Many pets have died (the Sportsmix products involved cat food too) and many more were left ill. (See recall info below for complete details.)

But even without the aflatoxin situation, this recipe was not a particularly good one to begin with. We normally like dog foods that start with a meat ingredient because that shows that meat makes up the most volume in the recipe. However, we aren’t sold on byproducts, and this recipe starts with one. 

When byproducts are mentioned, it means this is what is leftover after the meat is removed. So a chicken byproduct meal is essentially dried out chicken leftovers that may include organs (good) but also other stuff like hide, hair, or intestinal contents (bad). 

Are these harmful to your dogs? No. Are these nutritious? They can be. But are these high-quality ingredients? Definitely not. 

Aside from the byproduct meal ingredient, this recipe also contains meat meal. But that ingredient is ambiguous. What animal was used? Which part/s?

The thing about unnamed ingredients is that it could mean anything. The meat could be sourced from one animal or it could be sourced from several. It’s not a quality ingredient, that’s for sure.

Recall Info:  Just December of last year, Midwestern Pet Foods, which manufactures Sportmix, issued a voluntary recall for several of its products, including this recipe. Tests showed that aflatoxin, which is produced by mold, exceeded acceptable levels, leaving 28 dogs and cats dead and eight others ill. 

The recall involved 50- and 44-pound bags of Premium High Energy with an expiration of either March 2 or 3, 2022. The  recall was later expanded  (January 11, 2021) to include more recipes and the updated toll numbered over 70 dogs dead and at least 80 more ill.

Problem Ingredients:  Chicken By-Product Meal, Meat Meal 

Key Differences Between the Worst and Best Dog Foods

• The best dog food will  exceed the minimum nutritional requirements –  Whilst all commercially available foods will reach the minimum required nutritional levels, the minimum is not enough to make your dog fully thrive.
• Protein –  According to Kate Barrington at Petsumer.com, the best dog food will have over 25% protein. This should be ideally from all animal sources, without using vegetable protein.
• Fat –  The best foods will have at least 10% fat content.
• Enriched with  Omega-3 and Omega-6 fatty acids.
• The first five ingredients on the label  should not contain any fillers, by-products, or additives.

Different Types of Dog Food

Kibbles / dry food:.

• Cheapest and most popular
• Usually comes in the form of dry kibble
• Good for teeth
• Requires water with the meal
• Easy to store
• Fussy dogs might find flavor and lack of aroma unappealing

Wet Dog Food:

• Good for picky dogs
• A bit more expensive
• More hydrating than dry
• Easier to digest
• Tend to be higher cost
• Focus on raw/lightly processed ingredients
• Stores longer than kibbles
• Requires re-hydration

Dehydrated:

• A type of dry pet food
• Not cooked at a high temperature to lock in nutrients
• May need to be combined with warm water
• Easy storage
• Comparable in price with  dry kibble
• Raw food diet
• Can be pricey
• Very high in protein and fat
• Might be prone to bacteria
• Difficult to store

Human Grade:

• New to the pet food market
• Deliverable to your house
• Designed specifically for your individual dog
• Dog food made from the “kitchen” (aka Homemade)
• Guaranteed nutritional quality
• Much more expensive than other options

FAQs regarding General Dog Nutrition

Which dog food brands adhere to WSAVA standards? –  WSAVA stands for World Small Animal Veterinary Association and currently, only five brands align with both AAFCO and WSAVA guidelines.

What is the best vet recommended dog food? – Truth is, there is no real consensus among vets on which they recommend as the best dog food. This is because all dogs are different and unique. There is no one catch-all formula that would be perfect for any dog. We would, therefore, recommend searching for a well-regarded food that is high in protein and fat, and that your dog likes the taste of!

What foods should dogs avoid? –  There are more foods that dogs should avoid than could ever be listed here. Some common human foods that are poisonous to dogs are chocolate, caffeine, onions, garlic, tamarind and sweetcorn. Check with a veterinary website before you feed your dog anything that isn't marketed as canine food.

Is Grain Free dog food really better? –  Dogs have been found to have trouble digesting grains and therefore grain-free foods can help aid digestion. A grain-free diet for your dog will also mean that you are likely buying formulas with higher levels of vegetables, fiber, and proteins. This will help the development of your dog's coat and skin, as well as provide your dog with more energy. A grain-free diet has however recently been linked to a small increase in canine heart disease.

What dog foods are causing heart problems? –  The FDA has recently begun to investigate how grain-free canine formulas might increase the risk of canine heart disease. It's still too early to come to any major conclusions, but we will keep an eye out on this story as it develops.

When seeking the best pet food that are better for your dog, consider both wet and dry dog food options. Finding one that meets WSAVA and AAFCO standards ensures you're selecting the right food for your pet's nutrition.

By prioritizing quality ingredients and adhering to reputable guidelines, you can contribute to a happy, healthy dog. Explore different brands and types of foods to discover the optimal choice for your beloved pet.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 3.8 / 5. Vote count: 39

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

As you found this post useful...

Follow us on social media!

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?

Related Posts:

About The Author

Start typing and press enter to search

Best Dog Foods: Blue Buffalo vs Purina Pro Plan vs Taste of the Wild vs Royal Canin vs Nutro vs Diamond Naturals vs Ollie vs Farmer’s Dog & More

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Here’s how it works .

What’s the best dog food? That’s such an open-ended question, right? Dogs have very different dietary needs, depending on their age, allergies, and many other health concerns. We know it’s so hard to find the best dog food for your pup’s diet type and nutritional requirements, as well as your budget. So we’ve broken down some of the best dog foods on the market into specific categories to help you decide which is the best option for you and your pup’s needs.

Best Senior Dog Food: Purina ONE Vibrant Maturity

Best dog foods for diet type, life stages, health concerns & more.

As we said above, we’ve chosen our best picks for very different needs for your dog’s situation. But with all of our top picks, our experts always consider the quality of ingredients, company reputation, pricing, customer reviews, and many other factors. All of the following dog foods meet the standards of the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) for a nutritionally complete and balanced diet and are made in North America.

Best Fresh Dog Food: The Farmer’s Dog

Visit Website

The Farmer’s Dog features fresh, human-grade dog food made with all-natural ingredients. They personalize your dog’s ingredients and portion sizes based on your pup’s profile, including age, breed, weight, body shape, activity level, health concerns, and more. And they ship it right to your door within days of cooking.

They have four grain-free recipe options (chicken, turkey, beef, and pork) developed by board-certified American College of Veterinary Nutrition (ACVN) nutritionists and flash-frozen to preserve nutrients   and freshness. Recipes are packed with fruits, vegetables, lentils, fish oil, and a blend of vitamins and minerals and contain no fillers or preservatives and is great for picky eaters .

The Farmer’s Dog bases its pricing on your dog’s age, weight, and other factors.

• Plans start at $2/day
• Free shipping (you can customize shipping frequency)
• View all options

Our readers have access to  50% off your first box.  No code is needed; use this link, and the discount will be applied! You can also visit our  dedicated The Farmer’s Dog coupons page .

Full Review Of The Farmer’s Dog | More Fresh Dog Food Reviews

Best Dry Dog Food: Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula

View on Amazon

It’s hard to pick the best dry dog food from all of the excellent options on the market these days. But our experts pick Blue Buffalo Life Protection as the best overall dry dog food.

This reasonably-priced adult dog food recipe includes a great balance of high-quality lean proteins and carbohydrates, as well as LifeSource Bits — a super-healthy blend of antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals selected by holistic veterinarians and animal nutritionists to support your dog’s whole-health requirements.

This recipe contains no chicken by-product meal, corn, wheat, soy, artificial flavors, or preservatives. It’s not grain-free, but many experts believe that most dogs need healthy grains in their diet if they don’t have allergies. If you’re looking for a grain-free adult dog food option, see our review of Wellness CORE Grain-Free below.

Best Wet/Canned Dog Food: Wellness Complete Health

Wellness is a highly-rated pet food brand that uses natural ingredients (no fillers), focusing on whole-body health. They have an extensive line of high-quality wet and dry food for dogs and cats.

As with all of their dog foods, this canned turkey and sweet potato recipe is nutrient and protein-rich to give your pup plenty of energy and includes carefully selected ingredients to support immune and digestive health, as well as a healthy coat and skin. The only downside is that it’s a bit pricey.

• 12 cans (12.5 oz each): $48.96 ($5.22 / lb)

Best Budget-Friendly Dry & Wet Dog Food: American Journey

View on Chewy

Are you on a limited budget but want a high-quality diet for your pup? Chewy brand American Journey could be just the ticket. Their grain-free salmon and sweet potato kibble recipe is a customer favorite, but American Journey carries an extensive line of affordable grain-free and grain-inclusive dry and wet dog food.

They also offer puppy, senior, and limited-ingredient formulas. All feature real animal protein as the first ingredient (chicken, beef, lamb, duck, etc.) fortified with whole fruits and vegetables, omega fatty acids, and plenty of other nutrients for whole-body health. Another huge plus, their food contains no wheat, corn, soy, by-products, artificial preservatives, flavoring or coloring.

• 28-lb bag: $53.98
• 12 cans (12.5 oz each): $28.05

Full Review Of American Journey Dog Food

Best Dehydrated Dog Food: The Honest Kitchen Whole Grain Chicken

The Honest Kitchen is a highly-reputable brand that features 100% human-grade dog food in all of its formulas. Among their most popular offerings is this whole grain chicken dehydrated dog food, which includes such real whole food ingredients as free-range chicken , organic oats and barley, carrots, and bananas.

Their dehydrated formulas come in a variety of proteins (and grain-free options), all of which make an excellent stand-alone meal or delicious and nutritious kibble topper. The Honest Kitchen also offers human-grade kibble clusters, bone broth, goat’s milk probiotic boosters, treats, and more.

• 7-lb box (makes 28 lbs of dog food): $59.99

Our readers have access to  30% off your first order with the Honest Kitchen with coupon code CJ30 . Use this link to get started.

Full Review Of The Honest Kitchen

Best Dog Stew: Nutro Hearty Stews

If your dog loves a good chunky stew in gravy, Nutro Hearty Stews are a fantastic option. We recommend the roasted turkey, sweet potato, and green bean recipe, but they also offer beef, chicken, and lamb recipes.

All stews are grain-free, have real protein as the #1 ingredient, and include real vegetables, vitamins, and minerals. They’re also non-GMO and contain no by-product meal and no artificial preservatives, flavors, or colors. Nutro also has an extensive line of dry dog food and other wet food options.

• 12 cans (12.5 oz each): $39.36 ($4.20 / lb)

Full Review Of Nutro Dog Food

Best Raw And Freeze-Dried Dog Food: BARF World

A pioneer in the raw dog food industry, BARF World offers raw diets in multiple forms, including frozen patties, nuggets, chubs (tubes of raw blend), and freeze-dried nuggets. BARF, which stands for Biologically Appropriate Raw Food or Bones And Raw Food, claims that a raw diet can result in a pet free of allergies and digestive problems.

Their AAFCO-compliant food includes muscle meat, bone, fat, organ meats, vegetables, and fruits and contains no grains or preservatives. They deliver right to your door and have a 60-day money-back guarantee if you and your pup aren’t satisfied with their diet.

• Frozen: starting at $139.97 for 24 x 8-oz. patties
• Freeze-Dried: starting at $38.97 for nuggets (14 oz)

Use  this link  to get the best deal we can offer from BARF World.

More Top Picks For Raw Dog Food Delivery | More Top Picks For Freeze-Dried Dog Food

Best Raw-Coated Kibble: BIXBI Rawbble

BIXBI’s Rawbble line of dog food features  freeze-dried raw-coated kibble that’s grain-free and has limited all-natural ingredients . It’s made and sourced in the U.S. with fresh meat, carbohydrates from lentils and whole peas, fruits, vegetables, and essential vitamins and minerals. It comes in chicken, duck, lamb, and pork recipes.

A lesser-known dog food brand, BIXBI offers high-quality, all-natural dry, wet, freeze-dried dog food, and dog treats. They also have an impressive line of organic mushroom supplements formulated to support overall wellness and specific health needs, like digestive problems, skin allergies, joint pain, and more.

• 24-lb bag: $86.76 ($0.23 / Fl Oz)

Full Review Of BIXBI Dog Food

Best Natural Dog Food: Spot & Tango

Spot & Tango offers excellent fresh meals and a high-quality dehydrated dog food called Unkibble. Both options are made from all-natural, human-grade ingredients, including real meats, vegetables, fruits, and more (no fillers, additives, or preservatives).

They customize the ingredients and portion sizes based on a profile you fill out on their website, including your dog’s breed, gender, age, weight, body shape, activity level, health conditions, and other factors. Their shelf-stable Unkibble is a fantastic option if you want human-grade dog food but don’t have room in your fridge or freezer to store fresh meals.

Spot & Tango’s pricing is based on your pet’s age, weight, activity level, and more.

• Unkibble plans start at $7/week
• Fresh plans start at $15/week
• Free shipping (shipping is every 4 weeks)

Are you looking for a Spot & Tango promo code? Visit our  dedicated  Spot & Tango coupon page  to check out the latest offer and save.

Full Review Of Spot & Tango | More Top Picks For All-Natural Dog Food

Best Organic Dog Food: Castor & Pollux Organix

All of Castor & Pollux Organix’s dry dog food recipes are USDA-certified organic, made with 95% or more certified-organic ingredients, and cooked in an organically certified kitchen in the U.S. 

This chicken and sweet potato recipe is grain-free and made with non-GMO ingredients. The #1 ingredient is  organic, free-range chicken . It’s packed with all the nutrients your pup needs and a blend of organic superfoods, including flaxseed, blueberries, and coconut oil. It also contains no corn, wheat, soy, artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives.

Castor & Pollux Organix also offers recipes with healthy grains and for puppies , small breeds , seniors , and more.

• 18-lb bag: Check Amazon for availability

Best Ethically Sourced Dog Food: Open Farm

If you’re committed to purchasing only ethically (and sustainably) sourced dog food, then we think Open Farm is your best bet. Open Farm sources all meats from Certified Humane farms. Certified Humane  sets high slaughter, cruelty-free standards and restricts the use of hormones and steroids. The seafood adheres to both  Ocean Wise  and  Seafood Watch  standards. They also source all vegetables and fruits from local and regional partner farms.

Open Farm carries a huge variety of dog food products — grain-free and grain-inclusive kibble, fresh meals, freeze-dried raw dog food, wet food, treats, and more. They also have puppy and senior food, as well as seven different protein options, including fish, lamb, venison, etc.

Open Farm carries so many dog food types and formulas in varying sizes that we’ve only included a few pricing examples here. You can save 5% off if you sign up for auto-shipping.

• Beef Kibble w/ Grains (22-lb bag): $86.99
• Grain-Free Beef Kibble (24-lb bag): $94.99
• Beef Freeze-Dried Raw Dog Food (22-oz bag): $54.99
• Turkey Stew/Wet Food (12 packs of 5.5-oz. boxes): $47.99
• Fresh Beef Meal (16 lbs): $159.99

Get free shipping on Open Farm orders larger than $50   via this lin k .

Full Review Of Open Farm

Best Holistic Dog Food: Holistic Select Natural

Holistic Select Natural dry dog food is our top pick for the best holistic dog food (food containing special ingredients for overall body health). This lamb recipe includes optimal protein levels, plus prebiotics and probiotics, live yogurt cultures, digestive enzymes, and natural fiber to promote a healthy digestive system.

Omega 3 fatty acids from salmon oil and flaxseed support a healthy coat and skin. It also contains antioxidants (immune system), glucosamine (joint health), taurine (heart health), and more.

• 30-lb bag: $77.99 ($2.60 / lb)

Learn More About The Benefits Of Holistic Dog Food

Best Grain-Free Dog Food: Wellness CORE Grain-Free

If your pup has allergies or doesn’t digest grains well, Wellness CORE’s kibble is a great choice. It contains 34% protein (deboned turkey and turkey and chicken meal), 16% fat content, and 4% fiber.

This kibble also includes omega fatty acids from salmon oil and flaxseed to support a healthy coat and skin, as well as antioxidants, glucosamine, probiotics, and taurine for overall body health.

• 26-lb bag: $79.99 ($3.08 / lb)

Learn More About A Grain-Free Diet For Dogs

Best Dog Food For Sensitive Stomachs: Canidae Pure

A limited-ingredient dog food is often the way to go if your dog has a sensitive stomach , and Canidae Pure, with only eight base ingredients, may be a great solution for your dog’s tummy issues. This grain-free adult dog food contains real lamb, goat meal, venison meal, lentils, peas, tapioca, canola oil, and sun-cured alfalfa.

Not only are the real-food ingredients less likely to upset a dog’s stomach, but this recipe also contains all the essential vitamins and minerals and a blend of probiotics to promote a healthy gut.

• 24-lb bag: $74.99 ($0.20 / Fl Oz)

Best Dog Food For Allergies: Ollie

Ollie is another company that delivers personalized fresh dog food right to your door and can be an excellent option if your dog has allergies. Their all-natural, human-grade meals contain no soy, corn, or wheat, and they can customize ingredients based on your dog’s specific allergy issues (you just let them know when you fill out your dog’s profile).

Ollie offers four recipes (beef, turkey, chicken, and lamb), all of which include high-quality proteins, fresh produce, and healthy oils, vitamins, and minerals. Meals contain no preservatives, fillers, or artificial ingredients. Just keep in mind that they ship in bulk every four or eight weeks, so you’ll need plenty of freezer room to store their meals.

• Plans start at less than $4/day and average $8/day (depending on the size of your dog and portions they eat)
• Free shipping

Our readers can get  50% off their first box.  Use  this link  to take advantage of this offer   (no discount code needed).

Full Review Of Ollie | More Dog Food For Allergies Reviews

Best Dog Food For Skin Allergies: Purina Pro Plan Sensitive Skin & Stomach

Many pet owners say this Purina Pro Plan dog food formula works wonders with skin allergies compared to many alternative products. Its #1 ingredient is salmon , rather than traditional chicken, turkey, or beef protein sources that can aggravate skin allergies. It also contains no corn, wheat, or soy.

This formula is also fortified with live probiotics for digestive and immune health and contains easily digestible oatmeal as a healthy carbohydrate source. It’s also a good alternative to our top pick for the best dog food for sensitive stomachs .

• 16-lb bag: $54.48 ($3.40 / Pound)

Best Dog Food For Weight Loss: Hill’s Science Diet Perfect Weight

Many veterinarians recommend Hill’s Science Diet Perfect Weight for a healthy weight loss diet. In fact, more than 70% of dogs lost weight within ten weeks on this diet in clinical studies . It contains 28.7% lean protein and 11.2% fat, as well as a complete balance of vitamins, minerals, and amino acids with no artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives. However, this dog food isn’t grain-free or gluten-free if those dietary needs are concerns for your pup.

If you’re not a big kibble fan or your pup has special dietary needs, another fantastic option to help your dog lose weight is The Farmer’s Dog (our top pick for the best fresh dog food ). They can customize your dog’s food, including ingredients and portion sizes, for your dog’s weight loss goal.

• 28.5-lb bag: $139.99 ($4.91 / lb)

More Top Diet Dog Food Options & Weight Loss Tips 

Best Vegetarian & Vegan Dog Food: Wild Earth

Featured on Shark Tank, Wild Earth makes veterinarian-developed, nutritionally complete vegan kibble with no animal-derived ingredients. Their kibble is high in protein (31%) from all-natural, clean food sources plus superfood ingredients like oats, chickpeas, and sweet potato.

They also have vegan treats that contain the superfood koji, another great source of protein for vegan dogs. None of their products have artificial ingredients or fillers.

Subscribe for auto-shipping and save 30% off your first order and 5% on future deliveries.

• Starting at (4-lb bag): $39.00

More Top Picks For Vegan Dog Food

Best Insect-Protein Dog Food: Chippin

View on Amazon | View on Chewy

Insect-protein pet food is getting a lot of buzz these days as an allergy-friendly and extraordinarily sustainable alternative to traditional animal-protein diets. If you’re sold on the multiple benefits for your pup and our planet, we recommend Chippin’s dehydrated cricket dog food.

This grain-inclusive nutritious chow, which meets AAFCO standards for adult dogs, features human-grade cricket protein sourced from a family farm in Canada. It’s fortified with fresh fruits and veggies, omega-3s, essential amino acids, vitamins, and minerals. Chippin also carries an assortment of dog treats.

Chippin is also an eco-friendly option for pet parents with their food using 80%+ fewer resources than others on the market.

With Chippin, you can subscribe for auto-shipping and save 20% off your first purchase and 5% on future deliveries.

• 3.5-lb bag (makes 10 lbs dog food): $63.99

Full Chippin Review

Best Keto Dog Food: Ketogenic Pet Foods

Has your veterinarian recommended a ketogenic diet for your pup? Ketogenic Pet Foods Keto Kibble is an excellent choice for high-protein and very low-carb dog food. This all-natural kibble is loaded with vitamins and minerals and also contains probiotics for gut health and fish oil for skin and coat health.

It comes in two AAFCO-compliant formulas that contain organic chicken. Grain-free Keto Kibble is 60% protein, 16% fat, and 5% carbohydrates. And the Keto Foundation kibble recipe with brown rice contains 40% protein, 18% fat, and 5% carbs. Both recipes get positive customer reviews.

• Keto Kibble (8 lb-bag) : $49.99 ($6.25 / lb)
• Keto Foundation (18 lb-bag) : $66.99 ($3.72 / lb)

More Top Picks For Keto Dog Food

Best Homemade Dog Food

If you’re into homemade dog food, be aware that your dog likely needs vitamin and other nutrient supplements if homemade food makes up most of his diet, whether it’s vegan, vegetarian, or includes meat and animal products.

We recommend learning more about nutrition requirements for dogs. The book  Feed Your Best Friend Better: Easy, Nutritious Meals and Treats for Dogs is a good resource. Consult with your veterinarian to make sure your dog’s getting all the nutrients he needs.

Our Best Homemade Dog Food Recipes

Best Dog Food For Puppies: Taste Of The Wild High Prairie

This grain-free puppy food is packed with lean protein and all the vitamins and minerals growing puppies need. It’s made without grain, corn, wheat, fillers, preservatives, or artificial ingredients, so it’s easy for puppies to digest. It also includes healthy antioxidants from plenty of vegetables.

The flavorful kibble is small enough for puppies of all sizes to chew easily. And an added bonus — all of the ingredients are sustainably sourced.

More Top Picks For Puppy Food 

Best Dog Food For Small Dogs: Royal Canin Small Breed

Royal Canin is a high-quality dog food brand specializing in formulas for five different dog sizes, from extra-small to giant breeds. This formula has precise nutrition for small dogs ten months to 8 years old, weighing 9 to 22 pounds.

Its ingredients include lean proteins and L-carnitine to give your small dog energy while helping maintain optimal weight. It also contains fatty acids to support skin and coat health. The kibble is also an ideal size for small dog breeds. This formula isn’t grain-free or gluten-free.

• 14-lb bag: $59.99 ($0.27 / Fl Oz)

Full Royal Canin Review | More Picks For Top Small Breed Food

Best Large Breed Dog Food: Diamond Naturals Large Breed

Like Royal Canin, Diamond Naturals also specializes in dog food formulas for various breed sizes. Optimal protein, fat, and amino acid levels in this recipe provide the nutrients large breeds need for lean, strong muscles and to maintain ideal body weight.

This holistic formula contains glucosamine and chondroitin for joint health , probiotics for digestive health , and omega-6 and omega-3 fatty acids from superfoods to help maintain healthy skin and a shiny coat. It’s also made with sustainably sourced ingredients , including cage-free chicken, and contains no corn, wheat, fillers, preservatives, or artificial flavors or colors.

• 40-lb bag: $43.99

More Picks For Top Large Breed Dog Food

Veterinarian-recommended Purina ONE offers this formula f or dogs seven years old and up . It includes special vitamins and minerals to enhance physical energy and mental sharpness and support your dog’s immune system and eye health.

Natural sources of glucosamine also help with aging and aching joints. Real chicken is the #1 ingredient, and it contains no fillers. Purina also has a Vibrant Maturity wet food alternative if your elderly pup has trouble chewing kibble.

• 31.1-lb bag: $49.98 ($1.61 / Pound)
• 12 cans (13 oz each): $19.99 ($2.05 / lb)

Best Dog Food Delivery Services

If you’re strapped for time to shop for dog food in person, we can help you find the best dog food delivery services to help you take shopping off your plate. See our reviews of the best dog food delivery services , whether you need name-brand kibble, customized fresh dog food, or several other options. Many of the delivery services we review in that article can deliver the dog food we recommend here.

The information provided through this website should not be used to diagnose or treat a health problem or disease; it is not intended to offer any legal opinion or advice or a substitute for professional safety advice or professional care. Please consult your health care provider, attorney, or product manual for professional advice. Products and services reviewed are provided by third parties; we are not responsible in any way for them, nor do we guarantee their functionality, utility, safety, or reliability. Our content is for educational purposes only.

About The Author

Sally Jones, Researcher/Writer & Editor

Related posts.

Best Dog Food For Border Collies: Puppy, Wet, Dry, Fresh & More

Best Dog Food For Boston Terriers: Puppies, Adults, Seniors & More

Stella & Chewy’s Dog Food Reviews: Our Firsthand Experience

• Search Search Search …
• Search Search …

Dog Food Comparison Chart – Compare Dog Food Side by Side

Jump Down Page To Dog Food Comparison Chart – Listed from A to Z – Dog Food Reviews

This  dog food comparison chart  shows side by side comparison of ingredients, price & protein content. Best grain free, grain friendly dry, canned & raw dog food.

Look for what the food Does and Does Not Contain.  Compare Good Dog Food Ingredients vs. Bad Dog Food Ingredients. – Easy Side by side Comparison.

Go to: Top Best & Worst Dog Foods 

AAFCO Ingredient Definitions – Ingredients Allowed in Pet Food

Worst dog food Brands are corn based , use By-Products, unknown & contaminated meat sources, unnatural fillers, chemicals, preservatives, cancer causing MENADIONE SODIUM BISULFITE (Called Synthetic Vitamin K on the label), and other low grade (fillers) products.

DOGS ARE CARNIVORES – They need meat, not corn for protein!

Notice in some of the cheaper foods that there are several instances of the same cheap ingredient being used more than once, using different names. For instance the use of ground yellow corn and corn gluten meal.

Remember there are hundreds of pet food products available. Learn to understand labels & compare dog food.  Dog food comparison is essential.

A more expensive high quality dog food will definitely save you money in the long run as you will be raising a much healthier pet.

Dog Food Comparison Chart – Side by Side Comparison of Ingredients is Essential

You may also like

Toxic Food for Dogs – Human Food Your Dog Should NEVER eat

Toxic Food for Dogs is something that will make your dog sick or worse. Check this list out and be aware. If […]

Top 10 Dog Foods – Grain Free & DCM safe

Compare our Top 10 Dog Foods:

CANIDAE PURE  GRAIN FREE,   ORIJEN  GRAIN FREE, BLUE BUFFALO GRAIN FREE,  WELLNESS CORE GRAIN FREE,  INSTINCT  RAW BOOST GRAIN FREE, WYSONG,   TASTE OF THE WILD GRAIN FREE,  ACANA GRAIN FREE,  MERRICK GRAIN FREE, AMERICAN JOURNEY GRAIN FREE,

Diamond Dog Food Review – Grain Free & Grain Friendly

Diamond Naturals Dog Food, Diamond Naturals Grain Free  Dog Food, Diamond Care Dog Food, Diamond is FAMILY OWNED & run, MADE in […]

Taste of the Wild Dog Food Review-Grain Free/Ancient Grains

  Taste of the Wild Dog Food Review: Taste of the Wild Grain Free Dog Food Review, Taste of the Wild Ancient […]

Hepper is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more .

Dog Food Reviews 2024 – Brands & Ratings

By Nicole Cosgrove

Updated on Jan 6, 2024

Click to Skip Ahead

Best dog food by type.

Best Dog Foods

Best Wet Dog Food

Best Dry Dog Food

Dog Food Reviews by Size

Small Breeds

Medium Breeds

Large Breeds

Dog Food Reviews By Brand (A to Z)

• A Pup Above
• 4health Grain Free
• 4health Original Puppy Formula
• Acana Pacifica
• Aldi Pure Being
• American Journey
• Authority Grain Free
• Bench & Field
• Black Gold Explorer
• Blue Buffalo Basics
• Blue Buffalo
• Blue Buffalo Life Protection
• Blue Buffalo Puppy
• Blue Buffalo Wilderness
• Bully Max High Performance
• Canidae All Life Stages
• Castor & Pollux
• Chewy Goody Box
• Diamond Care
• Diamond Naturals
• Diamond Naturals Grain Free
• Diamond Puppy
• Earth Born Holistic
• Fresh Pet Select
• Fresh Pet Vita Grain Free
• Front Line Plus
• Gentle Giants
• Gravy Train
• Greenies Dog Treats
• Halo Holistic  
• Heritage Ranch
• Hills Science Diet
• Hungry Bark
• Iams Proactive Health
• Instinct Raw Boost
• Kibbles & Bits
• K9 Advantix ii
• Kirkland and Costco
• Kirkland and Signature Nature’s Domain
• Life’s Abundance
• Members Mark

Merrick Backcountry

• Merrick Grain Free
• Natural Balance
• Natural Balance Limited Ingredient
• Natural Balance Vegetarian
• Nature’s Logic
• Nature’s Recipe
• Nom Nom Now
• Nutra Complete
• Nutra Nuggets
• Nutrisource
• Nutricanine
• Nutro Farms Harvest
• Nutro Grain Free
• Nutro Puppy
• Nutro Wholesome Essentials

Ollie Fresh

• Only Natural
• Orijen Regional Red
• Orijen Senior
• Orijen Six Fish
• Performatrin
• Pure Balance
• Pure Balance Grain Free
• Purina Bella
• Purina Beyond Grain Free
• Purina Bright Mind
• Purina Dentalife
• Purina Moist Meaty
• Purina One Smartblend
• Purina Pro Plan Savor
• Purina Pro Plan Sport
• Purina Puppy Chow
• Rachael Ray Nutrish
• Rachael Ray Nutrish Peak
• Rachael Ray Zero Grain
• Raw Paws 6 Inch Green Beef Tripe Stick
• Royal Canin
• Royal Canin German Shepherd
• Royal Canin Hydrolyzed Protein
• Royal Canin Puppy
• Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Gastrointestinal Low Fat
• Simply Nourish
• Spot & Tango
• Sundays for Dogs
• Supreme Source
• Taste of The Wild
• Taste of The Wild High Prairie
• Taste of The Wild Pacific Stream
• Taste of The Wild Prey
• Taste of The Wild Wetlands
• The Farmers Dog

The Honest Kitchen

• Trisha Yearwood
• Vital Essentials Chicken Nibblets Review

Wellness Core

• Wellness Simple
• Whimzees Dog Treats
• Wholehearted

Fresh Dog Food Reviews- Our Favorites

The Farmer’s Dog

Brand vs Brand Comparisons

• 4Health vs Taste of the Wild
• 4Health vs Blue Buffalo
• 4Health vs Purina Pro Plan
• Abound vs Blue Buffalo
• Acana vs Fromm
• Acana vs Orijen 
• American Journey vs Blue Buffalo
• American Journey vs Taste of the Wild
• Authority vs Hills Science Diet
• Blue Buffalo vs Hills Science Diet
• Blue Buffalo vs Purina Pro Plan
• Blue Buffalo vs Taste of the Wild
• Blue Buffalo vs Wellness
• Bully Max vs Bully Max Pro
• Canidae vs Blue Buffalo
• Carna4 vs Orijen
• Dr. Marty’s vs The Farmer’s Dog
• Fromm vs Blue Buffalo
• Fromm vs Orijen 
• Iams Proactive vs Hills
• Iams vs Blue Buffalo
• Iams vs Pedigree 
• Iams vs Purina
• Kirkland Natures Domain vs Taste of the Wild
• Kirkland vs Blue Buffalo
• Members Mark vs Kirkland
• Members Mark vs Purina Pro
• Merrick vs Acana
• Merrick vs Blue Buffalo
• Merrick vs Wellness
• Natural Balance vs Blue Buffalo
• Nom Nom vs The Farmer’s Dog
• Nutro vs Blue Buffalo
• Open Farm vs Stella & Chewy
• Orijen vs Blue Buffalo
• Pedigree vs Purina
• Primal vs Stella & Chewy’s
• Pro Pac vs Blue Buffalo
• Pure Balance vs Blue Buffalo
• Purina Beneful vs Bil Jac
• Purina Dog Chow vs Kibbles n Bits
• Purina One vs Blue Buffalo
• Purina Pro Plan vs Hills
• Purina Pro Plan vs Iams Proactive
• Purina Pro Plan vs Kirkland
• Purina Pro Plan vs Purina One
• Royal Canin vs Blue Buffalo 
• Royal Canin vs Hills Science
• Royal Canin vs Kirkland
• Royal Canin vs Purina Pro
• Sundays vs Spot & Tango
• Taste of the Wild vs Acana
• Taste of the Wild vs Orijen
• The Farmer’s Dog vs JustFoodforDogs
• The Farmer’s Dog vs Spot & Tango
• Victor vs Bully Max
• Victor vs Blue Buffalo
• Victor vs Diamond
• Victor vs Purina Pro Plan
• Victor vs Taste of the Wild
• The Farmer’s Dog vs Ollie Fresh
• Wag vs Blue Buffalo
• Wag vs Taste of the Wild

Dog Food Ratings - Top 12 Brands

Below you’ll find our dog food ratings of the top 12 brands. The ratings are determined by our team who review and test the products on various criteria such as nutrition, price, texture, and favorability toward dogs – so rest assured, you’re getting an authentic opinion of quality!

Instinct Raw

Taste of the Wild

Purina Beyond Grain-Free

Food Reviews by Lifestage

• Best Food for Puppies
• Best Wet Food for Puppies
• Best for Toy Breeds
• Best for Small Breeds
• Best for Large Breeds
• Best Grain Free
• Best Organic
• Best for Sensitive Stomachs
• Best Vet Recommended 

Adult & Senior

• Best Food for Senior Dogs
• Best Wet Food for Senior Dogs
• Best for Small Senior Dogs
• Best Food for Arthritis
• Best Food for Weight Loss
• Best Wet Food for Senior Dogs Best Senior Dog Food for Arthritis
• Best Senior Dog Food for Weight Loss

Puppy Food by Breed

Best for Australian Shepherd Puppies Best for Beagle Puppies Best for Boston Terrier Puppies Best for Border Collie Puppies Best for Boxer Puppies Best for Cane Corso Puppies Best for Chihuahua Puppies Best for Corgi Puppies Best for Dachshund Puppies Best for French Bulldog Puppies Best for Goldendoodle Puppies Best for Golden Retriever Puppies Best for Great Dane Puppies Best for Great Pyrenees Puppies Best for Husky Puppies Best for Lab Puppies Best for Labradoodle Puppies Best for Maltipoo Puppies Best for Maltese Puppies Best for Mastiff Puppies Best for Pitbull Puppies Best for Pug Puppies Best for Rottweiler Puppies Best for Schnauzer Puppies Best for Shih Tzu Puppies Best for Yorkie Puppies

Adult/Senior Food by Breed

• Affordable Foods for Labs
• Affordable Foods for Pitbulls
• Best Foods for Active Dogs
• Best Food for Shih Tzus with Allergies
• Best Food for Boxers with Gas
• Best Food for French Bulldogs with Allergies
• Best Food for French Bulldogs with Gas
• Best Food for German Shepherds with Allergies
• Best Food for Great Danes with Sensitive Stomachs
• Best Food for Huskies to Gain Weight
• Best Food for Pitbulls with Skin Allergies
• Best Food for Poodles with Sensitive Stomachs
• Best Food for Schnauzers with Skin Allergies
• Best Food for Senior Chihuahuas
• Best Food for Small Senior Dogs
• Best Food for Yorkies with Allergies
• Best Food for German Shepherds to Gain Weight
• Best Wet Food for Chihuahua

Dog Food Reviews by Breed

Golden Retriever

Dog Food Reviews by Health Condition

Dog food reviews by type.

• Best Dog Food
• Beef Dog Foods
• Best-Tasting Food for Picky Eaters
• Budget Dog Foods
• Cheap Puppy Food
• Freeze Dried
• For Active Dogs
• For All Life Stages
• For Hunting Dogs
• For Large Breeds
• For Medium Dogs
• For Puppies
• For Small Dogs
• For Toy Breeds
• For Pregnant Dogs
• High Protein
• Holistic Dog Food
• Human Grade Brands
• Lamb Dog Foods
• Large Breed Puppy Food
• Low Protein
• Made In The USA
• Organic Puppy
• Puppy Food for Toy Breeds
• Raw Dog Food
• Salmon Dog Food
• Senior Dog Food
• Soft Dry Dog Food
• Venison Dog Foods
• Vet-Recommended Food 
• Walmart Dog Food
• Wet Puppy Food
• With Probiotics
• Without Chicken
• Without Legumes Peas and Lentils
• Without Potatoes
• With Grains

How We Rate Dog Food

Customer satisfaction.

Hepper is heavily focused on serving consumers of pet products, which is why we value customer satisfaction so highly in our dog food review process. We scour online platforms to determine whether dog owners feel satisfied with the product they are investing in for their loved ones. We read a host of reviews on major retail outlets like Amazon and Chewy, and we even offer a section on what users are saying in our reviews for increased transparency. We read forums and articles across the internet in order to gain a fully faceted picture of what is being offered, from packaging to kibble size.

Analysis of the Primary Ingredients

We evaluate the quality of primary ingredients by judging the ratio of essential components that make up a sustained, health-based canine diet. In a top-rated dog food, we expect to see a combination of high-quality, identified meat and fat-based products along with the addition of whole grains, fruits, and vegetables. We scrutinize ingredient lists for unhealthy fillers and make sure to openly identify the addition of any controversial ingredients or harmful additives.

Recall History

We research past recalls in order to provide as much information as possible to pet owners investing in a new dog food so that they can feel safe about their decision. Not only do we take into account the recall itself, but we also weigh the severity of the incident as well as how the company responded to the instance. We offer full transparency around brands’ recalls within our reviews, even if they occurred in another pet food category. This allows our readers to be armed with the facts in order to make the most informed purchases.

We know that price plays a crucial role in canine nutrition, that’s why we use it as an important variable when rating dog food. First, we measure the amount of low-cost fillers versus premium ingredients in a recipe to judge whether the price matches the value. Then we conduct a side-by-side comparison of ingredients offered with competing brands at a similar price point.

Featured Image credit: alexei_tm, Shutterstock

Related Articles

Further Reading

10 Best UVB Light for Bearded Dragon 40-Gallon Tanks – 2024 Reviews & Top Picks

Jan 17, 2024 - 12 min read

What Size Cage Do Parakeets Need? Vet Approved Advice & FAQ

Jan 9, 2024 - 4 min read

British Shorthair vs Scottish Fold Cats: The Differences (With Pictures)

Jan 25, 2024 - 7 min read

Vet Articles

Latest Vet Answers

The latest veterinarians' answers to questions from our database

Can Angelfish & Betta Fish Live Together? Our Vet Explains

Answered by Dr. Luqman Javed, DVM (Vet)

Rabies in Dogs: Causes, Signs & Care Guide

Answered by Dr. Iulia Mihai

How to Help an Abused Dog Recover: 8 Tips & Tricks

Answered by Dr. Sharon Butzke, DVM (Vet)

Can Betta Fish and Goldfish Live Together? Fish Compatibility Explained By Our Vet

Why You Should Never Buy a One-Gallon Fish Tank: Our Vet Explains

Answered by Dr. Paola Cuevas, MVZ (Vet)

Dog Ear Hair Plucking: Our Vet Answers Concerns & Alternatives

Answered by Dr. Karyn Kanowski, BVSc MRCVS (Vet)

Cat food recalls

Have a cat? Stay on top of cat food recalls here >

Dog food recalls

Have a dog? Stay on top of dog food recalls here >

Have a question? talk to a vet online for advice >

Blue Buffalo vs Purina Pro Plan: Which Dog Food is Better?

Let's compare Blue Buffalo to Purina Pro and find which offers your pup the best dog food. We explore each origin story, recall history, as well as dig into each life stage to determine which brand has the more robust and nutritious offering for your puppy, adult, or senior dog.

Last Updated: August 31, 2022 | 9 min read

Note: Clicking the above links will take you to Chewy.com, where you can get additional product information and customer reviews. If you make a purchase, we earn a commission at no additional cost to you.

We often share common interests with our canine besties, and if you’re anything like us, a love of food is one of them. That’s why finding the right food for Fido that is both healthy and tasty is so important.

We look at two food brands. Blue Buffalo is popular for whole food source ingredients, and Purina Pro is a favorite vet recommendation. Your pup’s food isn’t just for taste; it dictates their health. Poor quality food doesn’t deliver the nutrition they need, so it is best avoided altogether. Choosing a brand that uses good quality ingredients and takes care to balance their recipe to meet your furry friend’s needs is the number one priority.

Let’s break down each brand’s history, recall history, formulas, and flavors. And, of course, what they offer your pup based on size and age. So, let’s discover which one is right for Fido. Let’s get cracking!

Top Pick For Puppies

Blue Buffalo Puppy

Top Pick For Adults

Blue Buffalo Life Protection

Top Pick For Seniors

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Senior

Brand History

Both Purina Pro and Blue Buffalo are giants of the pet food industry . But that’s where the similarities stop. Purina has a long 120-year history of researching and developing animal food of all kinds. On the other hand, Blue Buffalo is relatively new in brand terms, founded in just 2003. But they are already a major player in the market. Each brand has a different route to success, and these differences add uniqueness to the brand’s mission. So, let’s take a closer look.

Blue Buffalo

Blue Buffalo was founded in 2003 by Bill Bishop and is headquartered in Wilton, Connecticut. Blue was the Bishop family pet for many years. As he aged and suffered from ailments, the family investigated the power of quality food to heal and keep dogs healthy. In honor of his beloved dog ‘Blue,’ Bill set out on a mission to create natural, healthy, good quality food for dogs.

Blue Buffalo makes multiple pet products for dogs and cats, including canned wet food, dry kibble, and treats. They have a huge following for their quality food ethos. In 2017, they recorded market sales  of over $1 billion . In 2018, this led to an  $8 billion acquisition by General Mills , makers of Cheerios.

Purina (originally Purina Mills) traces its roots to 1894 when founder William H. Danforth established the animal feed company Purina Mills. After decades of name changes and mergers and acquisitions with other pet food companies, the business was purchased by Swiss-based Nestlé (makers of Friskies) in 2001. It is now one of the world’s biggest pet food companies with a dedicated research and design center for food as well as a dedicated animal health research center that influences the recipes they use to create the best food possible. So, it’s safe to say that Purina is a global success.  

Now that we know each brand’s history, let’s discuss their past dog food recalls. According to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), recalls are actions taken by a firm to remove a product from the market. Recalls may be conducted on a firm’s own initiative, by FDA request, or by FDA order under statutory authority. The speed at which a brand handles a recall and when they issue it can say a lot about their interest in our dog’s welfare . Let’s take a closer look.

Blue Buffalo has one recorded recall on the FDA website. But have voluntarily issued some recalls for various reasons covering food quality and packaging defects. We found five in total, with just three that posed a potential risk. All were issued and managed rapidly, with full details given to owners of the dangers posed and the severity of the risk. All were low.

The recalls that have come from Blue Buffalo include:

• October 8, 2010 : Blue Buffalo announced a dog food recall of specific batches of some of its popular products due to potentially toxic vitamin D levels.
• March 17, 2017 : Blue Buffalo voluntarily recalled one production lot of Blue Wilderness Rocky Mountain Recipe Red Meat Dinner wet food. It might have contained elevated levels of naturally occurring beef thyroid hormone.
• February 13, 2017 : Blue Buffalo issued a voluntary recall for specific lots of Blue Buffalo Homestyle Recipe Healthy Weight due to possible aluminum metal contamination.
• March 2, 2017 : Blue Buffalo issued a voluntary market withdrawal of 17 varieties of its Blue Divine Delights and Blue Wilderness Trail Trays. This was due to quality issues with the foil seals on the top of the cups.
• May 31, 2016 : Blue Buffalo voluntarily recalled a limited batch of its Life Protection Formula Dog Food product due to the presence of excessive moisture and mold.

Purina Pro as a brand has had no recalls, according to the FDA website. Other sources show one recall for the Pro Plan wet dog food. Clearly, this is a better record than Blue Buffalo’s recall record. Purina’s one recall is as follows:

• March 10, 2016 : Purina voluntarily recalled select lots of its Beneful and Purina Pro Plan wet dog foods. This was because they might not have contained the recommended level of vitamins and minerals.

Food Ingredients

Both Blue Buffalo and Purina Pro pride themselves on using high-quality food ingredients in their formulas. To that end, they both have promises they make to their customers regarding the ingredients that go into their pet food. By looking at the ingredients, we can make an informed decision about what we feed them. With that in mind, let’s look at both brands and see what they use.

At Blue Buffalo, their promise is quite simple. They promised their little boy Blue (the family Airedale terrier) that they would create the healthiest food they possibly could. And their pet food range extends that promise to our furry friends and us. The major part of that promise is that they will always use real meat as the first ingredient . That means they will not use any chicken or poultry by-product meals, which are lower-quality protein sources, as well as no artificial flavors, preservatives, corn, wheat, or soy.

Their in-house team of veterinarians and animal nutritionists design the recipes backed by science and conscientious research. They carefully selected high-quality natural ingredients such as whole meat products and real sources of vegetables and fiber. Their ‘True Blue’ promise assures us that we can feed our pets this food, knowing it will deliver what they need for a healthy balanced diet and continued good health.

Purina Pro Plan

​The Purina Pro Plan vision, mission, and ethos have been developed over 90+ years of passionate experience and innovative research . They believe that the power of good nutrition is key to extending and improving the lives of our pets. Purina Pro Plan promises that every product recipe is guaranteed to provide 100% of the essential nutrients your pet’s body requires.

They have an impressive team of over 500 scientists and pet care experts who develop their foods . This pet food army has the sole focus of creating breakthroughs in animal nutrition. By looking at the needs of specific life stages, health conditions, breeds, and sizes, they guarantee that the food they produce will be near to perfect for your pup.

Purina Pro almost always lists meat as the first ingredient, but this is not always the case. If their scientific research dictates that this is not what the target audience needs, it will use something else. In their grain-inclusive recipes, they use corn, wheat, soy, and meat by-product meals . Some critics state that manufacturers shouldn’t use these ingredients. But Purina Pro Plan is led by science, and their formulas are highly rated. So whether you feed your pup, these ingredients will depend on where you sit on this discussion.

Range of Formulas

Both Blue Buffalo and Purina Pro offer a wide range of formulas. For many years, dog owners found a food that their dog liked and fed it to them for their complete lifespan. But now, with the advances of science and research, we know that our dogs have multiple life stages . All of which require different nutritional intakes as they grow and age. This means their food needs to change as they do. Lucky for us, both Blue Buffalo and Purina Pro Plan have us covered on that front.

Puppy Formulas

Blue Buffalo Small Breed Puppy

• All-natural small breed puppy food.
• Real meat is the first ingredient.
• No meat by-products.
• No fillers or artificial ingredients.
• Contains blueberries, peas & carrots (Fiber).
• Antioxidant-rich formula includes sweet potatoes.
• Smaller size kibble for puppy jaws.

Blue Buffalo has puppy formulas in five of its seven product lines. Life Protection, Blue Wilderness, Blue Freedom, Blue Basics, and Baby Blue cover various puppy dietary needs across sizes and sensitivities. In all recipes, whole meat is the first ingredient.

Purina Pro offers ten puppy products , covering various sizes, dietary requirements, and health issues. Each option has heightened omega fatty acids to supply the all-important DHA and ARA needed for brain and vision development.

The winner of the puppy formulas round is Blue Buffalo . This is due to their numerous options for our pups. In total, across the five ranges, there are 36 dry kibbles from which to choose. So, almost all puppy types and needs are addressed.

Adult Formulas

The longest stage of a dog’s life is adulthood, usually from one year through to seven or eight. Our adult dogs need high-quality nutrition to ensure they have lots of energy and to remain healthy. Let’s see what options each brand gives us in this category.

• Wide variety of flavors and types.
• Available as kibble or wet food.
• Comes in 7 types of proteins.
• Smart blended with other high-quality ingredients.
• Has Omega-6 and other nutrients for adult dogs.

Blue Buffalo offers a whopping 74 kibble varieties across seven ranges for adult dogs. The flavors include chicken, salmon, duck, beef, bison, rabbit, venison, turkey, trout, and quail. Plus, they have dedicated recipes that cover size and activity levels. There are also recipes catering to all-sized dogs, from toys to giant breeds. That’s a lot of flavors and tailoring.

Purina Pro offers 23 dry kibble diets for our adult dogs. With different offerings to cater to the size of your dog and energy needs. There are high protein diets for athletic dogs. In addition, they have weight management varieties for those who have a big appetite but don’t want a big waistline. Plus, there are ailment-specific kibbles designed to alleviate sensitive skin. When it comes to flavor, they offer chicken, salmon, or lamb.

Though the Purina Pro range is comprehensive and all-inclusive, the winner must be Blue Buffalo for the sheer vastness of choice and specific diet offerings they have. We love that a quick look at the recipes shows added antioxidants in the form of fresh blueberries and cranberries. Plus, their proteins are free from unnamed meat by-products.

Senior Formulas

Our aging canines in their senior years require additional supplements to aid them as they get old, tired, and stiff. More glucosamine from fish oils and meat meals are required for their joints. And they need fewer calories to ensure they don’t fatten up as they slow down. Let’s see what each brand offers in their senior formulas.

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Senior Food

• Grain-free food.
• High protein formula.
• Made with antioxidant-rich veggies.
• Deboned chicken is the first ingredient.
• Sweet potato aids digestion.
• 387 Calories per cup.
• 30% Protein, 12% Fat, 7% Fiber.

Blue Buffalo has senior-specific recipes in five of its product ranges, giving a choice of 14 different senior kibbles . These cater to different sizes and dietary needs. Like Purina, it has added vitamins and minerals with fish oils. They also offer senior-specific recipes in their natural veterinary diet range in addition to the 14 recipes. These offer kidney support, weight management, and food intolerances.

Purina Pro offers four senior-specific recipes . Two of these are for small and large breeds. One product contains botanical oils for a brighter mind, and the other is labeled complete essentials. Overall, the products contain fewer fats than the Purina Pro adult options. But in generic terms, the fats and calories per cup are higher than the average senior product. So, if your

Again, Blue Buffalo takes the top spot for its sheer inclusivity of all types of senior dogs, dietary needs, and ailment targeting. The recipes also include a wider range of ingredients for more flavor choices. Plus, their options have fewer fats and higher fiber content that suits most seniors’ needs.

Canned Foods

Canned food is a great way to add a diversity of flavor and texture to Fido’s food. It can even aid hydration in those dogs that struggle with dry food and bowel movements. Let’s see what each brand offers for canned yumminess.

Blue Buffalo Wet Food Homestyle

• Real beef as first ingredient.
• Perfect to mix with dry food.
• Supports lean muscle growth.
• Includes fruits and vegetables.
• 398 Calories per cup.
• 8.5% Protein, 6% Fat, 1.5% Fiber.

A quick search on the Blue Buffalo site shows 99 different products available under wet food. They come canned or in a trail-ready plastic food tray that you can take with you on your travels. The flavors covered include Blue’s stew, Backyard BBQ, and Mom’s chicken pie, to name but a few of the specialist recipes. Ingredients covered are beef, chicken, lamb, duck, venison, trout, and salmon. Puppies, adults, and seniors of all sizes have options. The list is almost endless…

There are 46 canned food options from Purina Pro. They all offer a range of flavor options, including beef, chicken, turkey, and fish. And it covers puppies, adults, and seniors, all within their different ranges.

You guessed it! Blue Buffalo wins this round as well. There are many recipes and flavors, and there are also size and age-specific wet foods available. The sheer choice and diverse range of needs covered are impressive.

Final Thoughts

Overall, both dog foods are the champions of good, well-balanced nutrition based on solid science and research. They use high-quality ingredients and wax lyrical about the need to customize your dog’s diet to their unique needs. That being said, when it comes to complete inclusivity and tailored ranges for almost every need, Blue Buffalo wins hands down . But that’s not to take anything away from Purina Pro. With decades of research and product development under their belt, they are still a top choice in most people’s books.

For us, if both brands have customized recipes for your pooch, it comes down to ingredients . If you are a fan of the cleaner and more natural ingredients, go with Blue Buffalo. But, if you are more convinced by science, Purina Pro might make the better choice for your stance. Whichever kibble brand you choose, you can rest assured that both options will benefit your pup’s lifestyle and nutritional needs.

Author's Suggestion

Purina Pro vs. American Journey: Which Food is Better For Dogs?

The information provided through this website should not be used to diagnose or treat a health problem or disease; it is not intended to offer any legal opinion or advice or a substitute for professional safety or care advice. Please consult your health care provider, attorney, insurance expert, or product manual for professional advice. Products and services reviewed are provided by third parties; we are not responsible in any way for them, nor do we guarantee their functionality, utility, safety, or reliability. Our content is for educational purposes only.

How much more expensive is Blue Buffalo compared to Purina Pro Plan?

I’ve been using Purina pro plan for sensitive stomach and skin but after reading the comparison between them and Blue Buffalo, im going to try him with the blue, hoping it will help with his constant chewing at himself and make his cost silky again.

Try adding Alaskan Salmon oil to the food. It really helps

I use Purina pro sensitive stomach, I use to use bluebufflo I do like Purina pro , it’s so confusing what you should put your puppy on cause you want the best for them

Leave a Comment Cancel Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More From Dog Food

Best Dog Foods For Weight Management: 6 Low Calorie Picks And Reviews

Best Dog Foods For Giant Breed Puppies: Ratings & Reviews

Best Dog Foods Without Legumes, Peas or Lentils: Ratings & Reviews

Purina Pro Plan & Purina One

First auto-ship, first auto-ship w/ code: pawdiet20, compare purina pro plan to, compare purina one to, brands similar to, ingredient reviews, purina pro plan vs. purina one, guaranteed analysis: purina one vs. purina pro plan, purina pro plan dog food vs. purina one dog food, crude protein comparison for dog food, crude fat comparison for dog food, purina pro plan cat food vs. purina one cat food, crude protein comparison for cat food, crude fat comparison for cat food, purina pro plan pet food ingredients vs. purina one pet food ingredients, canola meal, pea protein, brewers rice, wheat gluten, animal digest, caramel color, soybean flour, soybean hulls, corn germ meal, corn gluten meal, meat by-products, whole grain corn, whole grain wheat, ground yellow corn, powdered cellulose, poultry by-products, chicken by-product meal, soybean protein isolate, soybean protein concentrate, animal fat (preserved with mixed tocopherols), ground wheat, garlic powder, vegetable oil, poultry giblets, chicken by-products, poultry by-product meal, added color, menadione sodium bisulfite complex, menadione sodium bisulfate complex, pork fat (preserved with tbhq and citric acid), animal fat (preserved with tbhq and citric acid), product safety: recall history of purina pro plan & purina one, price comparison: which brand is more expensive, cost analyzer widget, cost of feeding purina pro plan, cost of feeding purina one, where to buy purina pro plan pet foods, where to buy purina one pet foods, type of pet foods available, top rated purina pro plan recipes, top rated purina one recipes.